Iseri M, Ustundag E, Ulubil A, Ozturk M, Bircan O: Synchronous ossiculoplasty with titanium prosthesis during canal wall down surgery for advanced cholesteatoma: anatomical and hearing outcomes. J Laryngol Otol. 2012 Feb;126(2):131-5.
OBJECTIVE: To analyse patients with cholesteatoma undergoing canal wall down mastoidectomy together with ossicular reconstruction with a titanium prosthesis, in order to identify factors associated with hearing outcomes.STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review of 97 cases undergoing single-stage surgical management. METHODS: All patients underwent canal wall down mastoidectomy. Kurz titanium ossicular prostheses were used for ossicular chain reconstruction. Pre-operative and post-operative air conduction and bone conduction hearing thresholds were obtained at 500, 1000, 2000 and 3000 Hz. RESULTS: The mean pure tone average improved from 46.02 ± 14.54 dB pre-operatively to 29.32 ± 14.64 dB post-operatively, for both total and partial ossicular replacement prosthesis groups combined. The mean air-bone gap improved from 30.38 ± 11.12 dB pre-operatively to 15.62 ± 9.65 dB post-operatively, for both groups combined. CONCLUSION: Reconstruction with a titanium prosthesis offers good functional results when performed during canal wall down surgery for advanced cholesteatoma, as a single-stage procedure.
Fong JC, Michael P, Raut V.: Titanium versus autograft ossiculoplasty. Acta Otolaryngol. 2010 May;130(5):554-8.
CONCLUSION: In this comparative series, hearing results were superior with titanium compared with autograft ossiculoplasty in the absence of a stapes superstructure. However, in the presence of a stapes superstructure, titanium ossiculoplasties gave superior results to autografts only when comparing an air-bone gap of < 10 dB. OBJECTIVE: To compare the hearing outcomes of autograft versus titanium ossiculoplasty at 1 year. METHODS: Two consecutive groups of patients with chronic suppurative otitis media with and without cholesteatoma suitable for ossiculoplasty, either primarily or as a staged procedure, were recruited for the study. A total of 52 consecutive patients who underwent an autograft ossiculoplasty were compared with 51 consecutive patients who underwent a titanium ossiculoplasty. Hearing results were statistically compared at 1 year between the two groups using the four frequency average (FFA) of 0.5/1/2/4 kHz and the American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (AAO-HNS) four frequency average of 0.5/1/2/3 kHz. The results were analysed statistically. RESULTS: A statistically significant number of titanium TORP ossiculoplasties achieved an air-bone gap closure to within < 20 dB compared with the autograft equivalent group (p = 0.039 FFA; p = 0.016 AAO-HNS). The number of titanium PORP ossiculoplasties achieving an air-bone gap closure to within < 10 dB compared with the autograft equivalent group was also statistically significant (p = 0.006 FFA; p = 0.002 AAO-HNS).
Rusiecka M, Bernal-Sprekelsen M: Footplate Reconstruction: Preliminary Results. Otol Neurotol 2014 Jun 20 (Epub ahead of print)
INTRODUCTION: A partially or fully absent or largely perforated footplate is a challenging condition that may be encountered during middle ear surgery, especially in patients with a history of chronic ear problems or with previous tympanoplasties.MATERIALS AND METHODS: Retrospective study on a limited number of cases undergoing revision tympanoplasty in which a new footplate was created from the cartilage, and the ossicular chain was reconstructed with a titanium prosthesis in 1 stage. Minimum follow-up was 24 months. Outcome measurements included the preoperative and postoperative bone conduction to assess the function of the inner ear, and the preoperative and postoperative threshold levels of air and bone conduction in 4 frequencies to assess the possible hearing improvement. RESULTS: Six patients could be included. The audiologic results showed the average air conduction gain of 11 dB. We did not observe any significant deterioration in the bone conduction which, in some cases, even improved (average change of +3 dB). The symptoms related to a perilymphatic fistula were resolved. The technique described herein has proven to be safe and reliable. CONCLUSION: Reconstruction of the footplate with autologous cartilage and simultaneous type III tympanoplasty seems to be a promising solution for those rare but challenging cases in which the footplate is partially of fully absent.
Birk S, Brase C, Hornung J: Experience With the Use of a Partial Ossicular Replacement Prosthesis With a Ball-and-Socket Joint Between the Plate and the Shaft. Otol Neurotol 2014 March 25 (Epub ahead of print)
BACKGROUND: In the further development of alloplastic prostheses for use in middle ear surgery, the Dresden and Cologne University Hospitals, working together with a company, introduced a new partial ossicular replacement prosthesis in 2011. The ball-and-socket joint between the prosthesis and the shaft mimics the natural articulations between the malleus and incus and between the incus and stapes, allowing reaction to movements of the tympanic membrane graft, particularly during the healing process.
STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective evaluation METHODS: To reconstruct sound conduction as part of a type III tympanoplasty, partial ossicular replacement prosthesis with a ball-and-socket joint between the plate and the shaft was implanted in 60 patients, with other standard partial ossicular replacement prosthesis implanted in 40 patients and 64 patients. Pure-tone audiometry was carried out, on average, 19 and 213 days after surgery. Results of the partial ossicular replacement prosthesis with a ball-and-socket joint between the plate and the shaft were compared with those of the standard prostheses.
RESULTS: Early measurements showed a mean improvement of 3.3 dB in the air-bone gap (ABG) with the partial ossicular replacement prosthesis with a ball-and-socket joint between the plate and the shaft, giving similar results than the standard implants (6.6 and 6.0 dB, respectively), but the differences were not statistically significant. Later measurements showed a statistically significant improvement in the mean ABG, 11.5 dB, compared with 4.4 dB for one of the standard partial ossicular replacement prosthesis and a tendency of better results to 6.9 dB of the other standard prosthesis.
CONCLUSIONS: In our patients, we achieved similarly good audiometric results to those already published for the partial ossicular replacement prosthesis with a ball-and-socket joint between the plate and the shaft. Intraoperative fixation posed no problems, and the postoperative complication rate was low.
Ashish Vashishth, MBBS, MS (presenter), Neeraj N. Mathur, MS, DNB, Deepak Verma: Cartilage Palisades in Type 3 Tympanoplasty: Functional and Hearing Results. Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg DOI 10.1007/s12070-014-0717-3
Objectives: Evaluate functional and hearing outcomes with use of full thickness broad cartilage palisades for tympanic membrane reconstruction in type 3 tympanoplasty using titanium prosthesis.
Methods: The retrospective study done at a tertiary referral institute included 30 patients with posterior mesotympanic retraction pockets or tympanic membrane perforations requiring tympanic membrane and a type 3 ossicular reconstruction. Patients with disease extending beyond aditus requiring canal wall down mastoidectomy were excluded. Disease removal from posterior mesotympanic and epitympanic recesses was confirmed using angled endoscopy and ossicular reconstruction performed using titanium partial or total ossicular replacement prosthesis. The tympanic membrane reconstruction was done, with or without attic reconstruction, using full thickness broad cartilage palisades harvested from the tragus with attached perichondrium laterally. Patients were assessed at 12 and 24 weeks for graft status and any evidence of implant extrusion. Hearing evaluation was done using subjective assessment and pure tone audiometry.
Results: Twenty-seven out of 30 patients had intact and completely healed grafts postoperatively at 24 weeks (success rate of 90%) displaying full union and epithelization of palisades, with 3 patients displaying small defects. The mean pure tone air bone gap pre and postoperatively was 32.4 dB and 8.8 dB respectively, with most patients reporting satisfactory postoperative hearing. No evidence of implant extrusion was found in the 24 week period.
Conclusions: Tympanic membrane reconstruction using full thickness palisades of tragal cartilage provides good functional and hearing outcomes in type 3 tympanoplasty using titanium prosthesis.
Meulemans J, Wuyts FL, Forton GE: Middle ear reconstruction using the titanium kurz variac partial ossicular replacement prosthesis: functional results. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2013 Oct 1;139(10):1017-25. doi: 10.1001/jamaoto.2013.4751
IMPORTANCE Satisfactory functional results following ossicular chain reconstruction mainly depend on a stable connection between the tympanic membrane and the stapes, which is in turn dependent on the type of prosthesis used. Knowledge about the safety and functional outcome of the commercially available middle ear prostheses is therefore of great importance. OBJECTIVE To evaluate the efficacy and safety of the Kurz TTP-Variac System partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) in ossiculoplasty. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS Retrospective review of all ossiculoplasties performed by 1 surgeon at a secondary referral center from August 2006 through July 2012. Participants were patients with cholesteatoma, chronic otitis media, or ossicular chain disruption in the absence of inflammatory disease who underwent ossicular reconstruction. EXPOSURE Ossiculoplasty using a Kurz TTP-Variac System PORP. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Mean preoperative and postoperative air-bone gaps (ABGs) and improvements in ABG were analyzed for each frequency by means of a 4-frequency pure-tone average. Successful postoperative hearing was defined as postoperative ABG smaller than 20 dB. RESULTS Eighty-nine ears in 83 patients aged 7 to 85 years were included. Transmeatal tympanoplasty was performed in 17 ears (19%). Seven ears (8%) underwent tympanoplasty with canal wall-down mastoidectomy, and 65 ears (73%) underwent canal wall-up (combined approach) tympanoplasty with mastoidectomy. The study population comprised 61 primary tympanoplasties (69%) and 28 revision cases (31%). Mean follow-up was 13 months. Overall, the ABG significantly improved from a mean (SD; range) of 26.19 (11.53; 3.75-51.25) dB to 15.58 (9.80; 0-48.75) dB (P < .01 for all frequencies). Mean ABG improvement was 10.62 dB. Successful postoperative hearing was obtained in 65 ears (73%). Revision surgery, especially in ears with ossicular chain disruption without inflammatory disease, was associated with poorer functional outcome, whereas preservation of the malleus was associated with a better functional outcome (P < .05). There were few complications (1 prosthesis extrusion, 2 prosthesis dislocations, 2 reperforations, 3 cases of residual cholesteatoma, and 3 of light sensorineural hearing loss). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE The titanium Kurz TTP-Variac System PORP is an effective prosthesis to reconstruct the ossicular chain. Complications are rare, illustrating the safety of the prosthesis.
Christof Roosli, Alexander M. Huber: Mid-Term Results After a Newly Designed Nitinol Stapes Prosthesis Use in 46 Patients. Otology & Neurotology 34:e61Ye64, 2013.
Objective: Analysis of 12-month midterm clinical and audiometricvdata of patients with otosclerosis who underwent stapedotomy using a newly designed prosthesis made of nitinol, a shape memory alloy.
Patients: Fifty-five ears of 50 consecutive patients who underwent stapetotomy between March 2010 and July 2011 were included. They met the inclusion criteria of primary procedures, a clinical follow-up and absence of nickel allergy.
Intervention: Stapedotomy and insertion of a newly designed stapes prosthesis.
Main Outcome Measures: Preoperative and postoperative (3 and 12 mo) air and bone conduction thresholds were recorded. Pure tone average and air bone gap (difference of air and bone conduction thresholds) were calculated for 500, 1,000, 2,000, and 3,000 Hz. The occurrence of complications was assessed.
Results: Air conduction thresholds, pure tone average, and airbone gap improved significantly 3 and 12 months postoperatively. Bone conduction threshold improved significantly at 2,000 Hz 3 months postoperatively and at 1,000 and 2,000 Hz 12 months postoperatively. A PTA of less than 20 dB was achieved in 96% of ears. No sensorineural hearing loss or other prosthesis-related
adverse effects were observed.
Conclusion: Postoperative hearing results are comparable to the results obtained with other self-crimping prostheses. No complications or failures related to the prosthesis occurred. A longer followup is necessary to prove long-term stability of hearing results and safety of the new prosthesis. Key Words: NiTiBONDVNitinolV OtosclerosisVStapedotomy.
Jeanette Hess-Erga, Per Møller, Flemming Slinning Vassbotn: Long-term hearing result using Kurz titanium ossicular implants. European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology, May 2013, Volume 270, Issue 6, pp 1817-1821
Titanium implants in middle ear surgery were introduced in the late 90s and are now frequently used in middle ear surgery. However, long-term studies of patient outcome are few and have only been published in subgroups of patients. We report the long-term effect of titanium middle ear implants for ossicular reconstruction in chronic ear disease investigated in a Norwegian tertiary otological referral centre. Retrospective chart reviews were performed for procedures involving 76 titanium implants between 2000 and 2007. All patients who underwent surgery using the Kurz Vario titanium implant were included in the study. Audiological parameters using four frequencies, 0.5, 1, 2, and 3 kHz, according to AAO-HNS guidelines, was assessed pre and postoperatively. Otosurgical procedures, complications, revisions, and extrusion rates were analyzed. The study had no dropouts. The partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) was used in 44 procedures and the total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP) in 32 procedures, respectively. Mean follow-up was 5.2 years (62 months). The ossiculoplasties were performed as staging procedures or in combination with other chronic ear surgery. The same surgeon performed all the procedures. A postoperative air-bone gap of ≤20 dB was obtained in 74 % of the patients, 82 % for the Bell (PORP) prosthesis, and 63 % for the Arial (TORP) prosthesis. The extrusion rate was 5 %. We conclude that titanium ossicular implants give stable and excellent long-term hearing results.
Robert Vincent, †Arnold J. N. Bittermann, ‡Gentiana Wenzel, §John Oates, ||Neil Sperling, ¶Thomas Lenarz, and †Wilko Grolman: Ossiculoplasty in Missing Malleus and Stapes Patients: Experimental and Preliminary Clinical Results With a New Malleus Replacement Prosthesis With the Otology-Neurotology Database. Otology & Neurotology 2013 Volume 34 Issue 1 pp 83-90
Objective: To present the preliminary results of new malleus replacement prosthesis combined with a total ossicular prosthesis in middle ear reconstruction in patients missing the malleus
Study Design: Prospective experimental and nonrandomized clinical study.
Setting: Tertiary referral center.
Methods: An original titanium malleus replacement prosthesis (MRP) was designed to be inserted into the external auditory canal and to replace a missing malleus for various middle ear pathologies. The MRP was tested experimentally and clinically. The vibratory properties of the new prosthesis were measured using laser Doppler vibrometry. Ninety patients with missing malleus and stapes, undergoing 92 ossicular reconstructions were enrolled in this study from September 1994 to March 2012. Comparative analyses were made between a group of 34 cases of ossicular reconstructions with total prosthesis (TORP) positioned from the tympanic membrane to the stapes footplate (TM-to-footplate assembly) and a group of 58 cases of ossicular reconstructions with TORP positioned from a newly designed malleus replacement prosthesis (MRP) to the stapes footplate (MRP-to-footplate assembly). Preoperative and postoperative audiometric evaluation using conventional audiometry, that is, air-bone gap (ABG), bone-conduction thresholds (BC), and air-conduction thresholds (AC) were assessed.
Results: Experimentally, the vibratory properties of the MRP are promising and remain very good even when the MRP is cemented into the bony canal wall mimicking its complete osseous-integration, if this were to occur. This finding supports the short-term clinical results as in the TM-to-footplate group; the 3-month postoperative mean ABG was 23.3 dB compared with 12.5 dB in the MRP-to-footplate group (difference, 10.8; 95% confidence interval, 4.0Y17.6); 37.0% of patients from the TM-to-footplate group had a postoperative ABG of 10 dB or less, and 48.1% of patients had a postoperative ABG of 20 dB or less, as compared with 58.1% and 79.1%, respectively, in the MRP-to-footplate group. The average gain in AC was 11.0 dB in the TM-to-footplate group as compared with 21.3 dB in the MRP-to-footplate group (difference, Y10.3; 95% confidence interval, Y18.2 to Y2.4).
Conclusion: The results of this study indicate that superior postoperative hearing thresholds could be achieved using a MRP-to-footplate assembly, compared with a TM-to-footplate assembly in patients with an absent malleus undergoing ossiculoplasty. The postoperative AC thresholds, after 3 months and 1 year, are significantly lower in patients treated with the MRP-to-footplate assembly.
Lauxmann M, Heckeler C, Beutner D, Lüers JC, Hüttenbrink KB, Chatzimichalis M, Huber A, Eiber A.: Experimental study on admissible forces at the incudomalleolar joint. Otol Neurotol. 2012 Aug;33(6):1077-84.
HYPOTHESIS: The forces that cause rupture of the incudomalleolar joint during the fixation of stapedial prostheses can be determined by means of load-deflection measurements at the long process of the incus. As in other tissues, 3 ranges of forces can be defined: micro rupture, rupture, and short-term maximum.
BACKGROUND: A crucial step in stapes surgery is the attachment of the stapedial prosthesis to the long process of the incus. It is unknown which forces occur during the crimping process that increase the risk of damage to the incudomalleolar joint or incus luxation. The goal of this study was to assess the admissible range of forces at the long process of the incus that would be tolerable before damaging the structures and to compare them with the forces occurring during surgery.
METHODS: Load-deflection curves in the lateral-medial and anterior-posterior direction were measured in 9 freshly frozen or fresh temporal bones. The force was measured with a load cell, and displacement was taken from the encoder information of the electrically driven translation stage on which the load cell was mounted. The long process of the incus was coupled to the load cell via a customized needle. We also monitored with video recordings for visual confirmation of findings.
RESULTS: The rupture force at which the middle ear was found to be severely injured was 894 (724-1018) mN in the anterior-posterior direction and 695 (574-771) mN in the lateral-medial direction. Micro-ruptures occurred at forces around 568 (469-686) mN in the anterior-posterior direction and in the lateral-medial direction at 406 (254-514) mN. Short-term maximum forces of 1,321 (1,051-1,533) mN were measured in the anterior-posterior direction and 939 (726-1,132) mN in the lateral-medial direction.
CONCLUSION: Rupture forces of the incudomalleolar joint could be defined with high accuracy. These results were used to calculate risks of incus luxation or subluxation during stapes surgery. Compared with the use of clip and SMA prostheses, the risk of damage from a crimping procedure is significantly higher.
Huber, Alexander M.; Schrepfer, Thomas; Eiber, Albrecht Clinical Evaluation of the NiTiBOND Stapes Prosthesis, an Optimized Shape Memory Alloy Design. Otol Neurotol. 2012 Feb;33(2):132-6.
Objective: To prospectively analyze short-term (3 mo) results in patients with otosclerosis who underwent stapedotomy with the newly designed NiTiBOND prosthesis and compare them with patients that underwent SMart piston stapedotomy. We aimed to assess “noninferiority” for the new prosthesis.
Study Design: Prospective controlled trial. Setting: Tertiary referral center. Patients: Thirty-eight patients were included in the NiTiBOND group (41 ears), and 74 patients were included in the SMart Piston group (75 ears). Intervention(s): Stapedotomy. Main Outcome Measure(s): Pure-tone audiometry 3 months after surgery, intraoperative prosthesis handling as assessed using a questionnaire, and complications were analyzed. Results: Pure-tone audiometry showed postoperative air-bone gap means (standard deviation) of 8.1 (8.3) and 9.9 (5.4) dB; air-bone gap closure within 10 dB was achieved in 71% and 72% and within 20 dB in 93% and 96% for the NiTiBOND and the SMart piston prosthesis, respectively. Noninferiority was shown at all frequencies and in the pure-tone average. The NiTiBOND prosthesis provides excellent intraoperative handling, and no adverse reactions were reported. Conclusion: Preliminary short-term results suggest safety and reliability for the new NiTiBOND stapes prosthesis.
Martins J, Silva H, Certal V, Amorim H, Carvalho C.: Ossiculoplasty with titanium prosthesis Acta Otorrinolaringol Esp. 2011 Jul-Aug;62(4):295-9. Epub 2011 May 6.
The goal of this study was to make a review of the patients who underwent ossicular chain reconstruction with titanium prosthesis during an eight-year period in our Department.
A retrospective study was made on the ossiculoplasty cases over a period of eight years in a Public Hospital District. The information was extracted by clinical process consultation. Between 1999 and 2008, 124 ossiculoplasties using Kurz(®) titanium prosthesis for chronic otitis media were performed (78 partial ossicular chain reconstructions and 46 total ossicular chain reconstructions). The single stage, staged and revision ossicular chain reconstruction were included in the analysis. All patients had a minimum of 6 month postoperative follow up (mean 3 years and 4 months). Comparisons of preoperative and postoperative pure tone averages were performed. Air-bone gap and implant extrusion rates were measured. The success of the reconstruction was defined as a postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) of 20 dB or better.
Successful ossiculoplasty was obtained in 73,1% of partial ossicular reconstruction reconstructions and 30,4% of total ossicular chain reconstructions (P<.05). The postoperative pure-tone average air-bone gaps was 16 dB in partial reconstructions and 26,7 dB in total reconstructions (P<.05). There were five cases of prosthesis extrusion.
The majority of the ossiculoplasties improved satisfactorily the hearing status. There was no difference in hearing results in one-stage and two-stage partial ossicular chain reconstruction, but there were better hearing results in the cases of two-stage total ossicular chain reconstruction.
Bremke M, Hüttenbrink K-B, Beutner D: The sandwich cartilage shoe technique for ossicular reconstruction in a case of an unsecure stapes footplate. Laryngoscope 121 (9): 1950-192.
This article describes a new surgical method for total ossicular reconstruction in a case of a broken stapes footplate. We developed the technique of the “cartilage shoe sandwich,” which consists of two surgical steps. First, the closure of the oval window is achieved by a cartilage shoe without a central perforation. During this surgical intervention, the prearrangement of a secure placement of a total ossicular replacement prosthesis is provided by a second cartilage with a central hole that is plugged with silicone. In a staged procedure, the silicone plug is removed and the ossicular reconstruction can be performed. The audiological results of the first patients show a stable inner ear function with an air-conduction gain of 9 dB. The technique described herein has proven to be safe and reliable in total ossicular reconstruction in the event of an unsecure stapes footplate.
Mantei, T, Chatzimichalis M, Hoon Sim J, Schrepfer T, Vorburger M, Huber AM: Ossiculoplasty with Total Ocssicular Replacement Proshesis an Omega connector: Early Clinical Results and Functional Measurements. Otology & Neurotology 09/2011: 32(7):1102-7
Objective: Among other difficulties, achieving a stable position of a total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP) is demanding because of a limited view on the TORP-footplate interface and individual angles between the footplate and tympanic membrane. The Kurz Omega Connector aims at a simplified insertion of the TORP. The performance of total ossicular reconstruction using the Omega Connector was evaluated.
Study Design: Prospective cohort study and experimental measurements with a fresh human temporal bone.
Setting: Tertiary referral center.
Patients: Seventeen consecutive patients receiving total ossicular reconstruction were included. Historical control group composed of 36 patients.
Interventions: Total ossicular reconstruction using the Omega Connector.
Main outcome Measures: (a) Handling of the TORP and Omega Connector intraoperatively, (b) functional short-term results compared with a historical control group, (c) sound transmission properties with 3 different connective positions between the TORP and the Omega Connector.
Results: Placing the Omega Connector on the footplate and coupling the Omega Connector to the TORP was straightforward in 65% of cases. A stable final position of the TORP was obtained in 88% of cases. Mean (SD) preoperative and postoperative air-bone gaps were 36.00 (11.05) and 25.29 (12.25) dB and were almost identical with those in the historical control group (p = 0.9). In the experimental measurements, functional outcomes with "partial connection" showed almost the same results as those with "full connection."
Conclusions: The Omega Connector provides easy handling of the TORP. The short-term functional results were comparable to those achieved previously without the Omega Connector. The temporal bone measurement supports tolerance in connective position between the TORP and the Omega Connector.
Schimanski G, Schimanski E, Berthold MR.: Diagnostic Findings in Stapes Revision Surgery-A Retrospective of 26 Years. Otology & Neurotology: April 2011 - Volume 32 - Issue 3 - pp 373-383
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the study is to obtain a detailed overview of the revision findings after stapes operations and to draw conclusions on a stapes prosthesis that can be recommended. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective case series. SETTING: Tertiary otologic referral center. METHODS: Approximately 12,000 middle ear operations within a period of 26 years were evaluated. The findings of the revisions were classified into surgeon related, prosthesis related, and other causes. RESULTS: Three hundred forty-three stapes revisions were done. Many different prostheses were found: the most common were Schuknecht prostheses and Teflon platinum, gold, and titanium pistons. Polyethylene strut, Teflon wire pistons, Shea (Teflon) pistons, and other techniques, such as columella or malleovestibulopexy, were rarely found. There are specific findings correlating to certain prostheses: Schuknecht prostheses were too short in 50% of the revisions (surgeon related), Teflon platinum caused necrosis or arrosion of the long incudal process (prostheses related) in 69%, and gold caused reparative granuloma sometimes combined with necosis of the incus in 70% (prostheses related). There was no specific diagnostic finding with titanium pistons, neither surgeon nor material related. CONCLUSION: An analysis of revision findings over an extended observation period can enable middle-ear surgeons to improve their surgical techniques and to select the best suited prosthesis. Self-fabricated stapes prostheses (e.g., Schuknecht) do not conform to required quality standards and should not be used. GoPi, which is no longer available, and TPlPi showed prosthesis-related diagnostic findings. The titanium prostheses used by the authors have proven to be excellently compatible and can therefore be recommended as safe stapes prostheses.
Herkenhoff S, Fischer B, Gleich O, Strutz J, Kwok P: A Micro-Computed Tomographic Study: Determination of the Angle Between the Tympanic Membrane and Stapes Footplate in a Total Ossicular Reconstruction Prosthesis Reconstruction. Otol Neurotol. 32 (3) 2011: 610-815
OBJECTIVES: To examine the anatomical relationship of the angles between tympanic membrane and stapes footplate and the variation of these angles among different temporal bones in order to characterize the optimal shape of total ossicular reconstruction prostheses (TORPs). METHODS: Ten specimens of human temporal bones were prepared for examination with micro-computed tomography. Five of the 10 temporal bones were implanted with 3 types of TORPs before subjecting them to micro-computed tomography. The angles between tympanic membrane and stapes footplate were determined. The contact of the TORPs to these structures was assessed. RESULTS: The angle between the stapes footplate and the tympanic membrane was, on average, 25.9 degrees in a plane along the transverse axis of the stapes footplate and 24.6 degrees in a plane along the longitudinal axis of the stapes footplate. Consideration of these angles in TORPs resulted in an optimal contact with the tympanic membrane and stapes footplate, especially for prostheses with a large foot. CONCLUSION: TORPs should be adjusted in shape before insertion into the middle ear. Further developments should consider prostheses with preadjusted angles or appliances for the exact modification of the prostheses during surgery.
Beutner D, Luers JC, Bornitz M, Zahnert T, Huttenbrink KB: Titanium Clip Ball Joint: A Partial Ossicular Reconstruction Prosthesis. Otol Neurotol. 32 (4) 2011: 646-9
OBJECTIVE: To describe a new titanium clip prosthesis for partial ossicular reconstruction with a micro ball joint in the headplate for compensation of tympanic membrane displacements. PATIENTS: Laboratory experiments followed by 18 consecutive patients.INTERVENTIONS: A micro ball joint was implemented into a headplate of titanium middle ear prosthesis. First, the new prosthesis was tested in the laboratory in temporal bone experiments. Second, the new prosthesis was clinically installed in 18 patients. OUTCOME MEASURES: Results of laser Doppler vibrometry and force measurements in the laboratory experiments, analysis of a questionnaire, and preoperative and postoperative pure tone audiometry. RESULTS: The frictional resistance in the joint was measured to be 12 mN that should allow for adequate mobility under physiologic conditions. The effective sound transmission of the prosthesis was demonstrated by laser Doppler vibrometry. Intraoperatively, the installation of the prosthesis was always straightforward with headplate prosthesis shaft angles between 60 and 90 degrees. Postoperatively, pure tone audiometry revealed satisfying hearing results with a remaining average air-bone gap of 18.2 dB over the frequencies 500, 1,000, 2,000, and 3,000 Hz. No signs of prosthesis dislocation were discovered within the follow-up period of approximately 6 months. CONCLUSION: The experimental data show that the new modified prosthesis headplate fulfills the requirements necessary for sound transmission. The joint allows the plate to follow movements of the tympanic membrane. This characteristic in conjunction with the proven clip design ensure for optimal prosthesis placement and effectiveness.
G.Schmid, U.Steinhardt, W. Heckmann: The Ω Connector - A Module for Jointed Coupling of Titanium Total Prostheses in the Middle Ear. Revue / Journal Title. Laryngo-, Rhino-, Otologie 2009, vol. 88, no12, pp. 782-788
Background: Hearing improvement after reconstruction of a defect ossicular chain depends on material, design and - crucially - coupling of the prosthesis. Coupling a total ossicular replacement prosthesis to the stapes footplate can be problematic and lead to prosthesis instability. In order to solve this problem, the Ω Connector was developed, a module allowing the middle ear surgeon to couple a titanium total prosthesis to the stapes footplate in a flexible, angle-variable manner.
Material and Method: The Ω Connector is made of pure titanium and consists of three compenents: head, neck and base plate. The head allows a jointed coupling to the stem of a titanium total prosthesis. Positioned between the remnants of the stapes crura, the bas plate proves for a stable connection with the stapes footplate.
Results: The Ω Connector was implanted during 14 revisions surgeries. In 10 of these surgeries a total ossicular replacement prosthesis was removed which was implanted at an earlier date and which was fixed and no longer functioning. In all 14 cases it was possible intraoperatively to position the Ω Connector correctly and to couple it to a titanium total prosthesis. The postoperative hearing gain was between 10 to 25 dB, with an average of 18 dB.
Conclusion: For the first time, the Ω Connector offers to the surgeon the option to couple a titanium total prosthesis via a micro ball joint. Hearing results achieved so far are satisfying. The results confirm the advantages of the Ω Connector during implantation of a titanium total prosthesis. For a final evaluation, long-term studies have yet to be made.
Dirk Beutner, Karl-Bernd Huttenbrink, Robert Stumpf, Thomas Beleites, Thomas Zahnert, Jan-Christoffer Luers, and Victor Helmstaedter: Cartilage Plate Tympanoplasty. Otology & Neurotology 00:00Y00 2009. Internet prepublished.
Objectives: The purpose of this work was to report our modified cartilage plate tympanoplasty technique ("tulip leaves") and to analyze its clinical outcome in primary and recurrent cases of chronic otitis media with and without cholesteatoma. Study Design: Clinical retrospective study. Methods: Patients being operated on with this technique at the University Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Dresden, Germany, between 1993 and 2001 were invited for survey, otomicroscopy, and pure-tone audiometry in 2003. Patients' charts were used to draw necessary conclusions. Results: A total of 39 patients who were treated with this technique after canal wall down tympanomastoidectomy and cavity obliteration were included in this long-term analysis after a median follow-up of 6 years. Seventeen patients (44%) experienced chronic otitis media with cholesteatoma, whereas 22 (56%) of them had a diagnosis of chronic otitis media without cholesteatoma. At the time of examination, all patients displayed a closed tympanic membrane. However, retractions were observed in 19 patients (48%). One patient required (3%) revision surgery for recurrent cholesteatoma due to prosthesis extrusion during the study period. Conclusion: On the basis of this study, we recommend the tuliplike arrangement of thin but large auricular cartilage slices for the reconstruction of tympanic membrane defects in high-risk ears. This combination proved its high stability and long-lasting vitality in our long-term study. These characteristics are crucial for permanent disease removal and for reducing the risk of recurrent pathologic abnormality.
Karl-Bernd Huttenbrink, Jan Christoffer Luers, and Dirk Beutner: Titanium Angular Clip: A New Prosthesis for Reconstruction of the Long Process of the Incus. Otology & Neurotology 00:00Y00 2009. Internet prepublished.
Objectives: To describe a new titanium angular clip prosthesis for bridging the incudostapedial joint in the event of an isolated lesion of the distal end of the long process of the incus. Study Design: Clinical retrospective study. Methods: We retrospectively reviewed the course of 22 patients with isolated defects of the long process of the incus where the ossicular chain was reconstructed by a titanium angular clip prosthesis. Results: The placement of the prosthesis was successful in all patients, and no complication was encountered during its installation. At the first follow-up visit after 3 weeks, the mean air-bone gap (ABG) was reduced by around 10 dB from a mean of 26 dB preoperatively to 16 dB postoperatively. The mean postoperative hearing result of patients with a Type A tympanogram (7-dB ABG) was consistently better than for patients with a Type B or a Type C tympanogram (19-dB ABG in both). Conclusion: Despite the limited number of patients, this preliminary study demonstrates the effectiveness of the angular clip prosthesis in reconstructing the ossicular chain. In cases of a normal aeration of the tympanic cavity, this reliable reconstruction of the biological chain offers a near-to-normal hearing restoration.
Joachim A. Hornung, Christoph Brase, Alessandro Bozzato, Johannes Zenk, Heinrich Iro, First Experience With a New Titanium Clip Stapes Prosthesis and a Comparison With the Earlier Model Used in Stapes Surgery Laryngoscope, December 2009
Objectives/Hypothesis: The aim of the study was to gain the first clinical experience with a new titanium clip prosthesis in stapes surgery, and to compare this model with its predecessor. We placed particular emphasis on the practicability of fixing the prosthesis to the long process of the incus and on the postoperative improvement in hearing. Study Design: Retrospective chart review. Methods: The study included 23 patients who had a CliP Piston áWengen fitted and 21 patients with a Soft CliP Piston (both from Kurz Medizintechnik, Dusslingen, Germany). Air and bone conduction were tested preoperatively and 5 to 6 weeks after surgery in all patients, as well as after about 1 year in a subgroup. Results: We found a mean air-bone gap of 8.5 _ 5.2 dB in the frequencies 0.5, 1, 2, and 3 kHz for the patients with a CliP Piston áWengen at follow-up audiometry after an average of 31 days, and of 6.4 _ 3.7 dB for 11 patients after 412 days. The corresponding figures for patients with Soft CliP Pistons were 8.9 _ 4.1 dB after 44 days, and 6.3 _ 5.6 dB for 10 patients after 419 days. There were no statistically significant differences. All the prostheses were implanted without difficulty. Conclusions: The two stapes prostheses studied gave good early audiometric results that showed no difference. After a short learning period, both could be pushed onto the long process of the incus with similar ease, although subjectively the new design of the Soft CliP seemed to adapt better to the different diameters of the process and took up less space in the middle ear. Key Words: Otosclerosis, stapes surgery, clip piston, crimping.
Forton, Glen E. J.; Wuyts, Floris L.; Delsupehe, Kathelijne G.; Verfaillie, Jan; Loncke, Robert CO2 Laser-Assisted Stapedotomy Combined With aWengen Titanium Clip Stapes Prosthesis: Superior Short-Term Results. Otology & Neurotology: December 2009 - Volume 30 - Issue 8 - pp 1071-1078
Objective: To report on the short-term results of CO2-laser assisted stapedotomy combined with the àWengen titanium clip stapes prosthesis. A comparison with published series using other prostheses and/or different stapedotomy techniques is made. Study Design: Retrospective case series. Patients: Patients with a history and audiologic data matching stapes fixation and computed tomographic imaging excluding other anomalies such as malleus fixation, dehiscent superior semicircular canal, and large vestibular aqueduct that may mimic stapes fixation-like hearing loss. Intervention: All patients underwent CO2 laser-assisted stapedotomy (Lumenis Co. Israel CO2 laser, Acuspot 712, SurgiTouch 870 scanner) and subsequent reconstruction by means of the àWengen titanium clip stapes prosthesis by Heinz Kurz Medizintechnik GmbH (Germany). Outcome Measures: Comparison and statistical analysis of preoperative and postoperative audiologic data. Results: Sixty-two stapedotomies were performed (61 patients) using the CO2 laser and àWengen titanium clip stapes prosthesis. The mean postoperative air-bone gap 3 months postoperatively was 5.1 ± 0.5 dB (standard deviation [SD], 4.1 dB; 0.5, 1, 2, 4 kHz). Air-bone gap closure less than or equal to 10 dB was achieved in 54 cases (87%). Air-bone gap closure less than 20 dB was achieved in all cases. The average gain was 27.8 ± 1.5 dB (SD, 12 dB; 0.5, 1, 2, 4 kHz). The average bone-conduction threshold shift or "overclosure" on 2,000 Hz was 13.6 ± 1.3 dB (SD, 10 dB). There was no postoperative perceptive hearing loss exceeding 15 dB on any measured frequency. The Amsterdam Hearing Evaluation Plots have also been used to evaluate our data. These data were statistically analyzed and compare favorably to other published series. Conclusion: The authors conclude that the combination of CO2 laser-assisted stapedotomy and the àWengen titanium clip stapes prosthesis is a combination likely to yield superior results in experienced hands.
C. Brase, J. Zenk, J. Wurm, B. Schick, H. Iro, J. Hornung: Steigbügelchirurgie. Erste Erfahrungen mit dem Einsatz des neuen Soft-CliP® Piston. HNO 2009:57(509-513). (German)
Background The first hearing results with a new stapes prosthesis with clip function (Soft-CliP® piston) are presented. Patients and Methods This new prosthesis was used in 15 patients (mean age 45.2 years; range 21-63 years) undergoing routine stapes surgery. Soft-CliP® piston prostheses with a shaft diameter of 0.4 mm and a length ranging from 4.25 mm to 5.5 mm were used. Postoperative audiological testing and measurement of the air-bone gap were performed after an average of 47.3 days and compared with the preoperative values. Results The median observed postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) was 8.33 dB ±4.16 dB. All patients had less than 20 dB ABG and in 53.3% of cases was less than 10 dB. The operating time showed a clear difference between the left (66.5 min ±37.79 min) and right ears (47.2 min ±11.08 min). Discussion This new prosthesis design greatly facilitates a very difficult step in stapes surgery, the prosthesis fixation to the incus. The first postoperative hearing results are very promising but long-term results in a larger group of patients are still pending.
Beutner D, Luers JC, Huttenbrink KB: Cartilage 'shoe': a new technique for stabilisation of titanium total ossicular replacement prosthesis at centre of stapes footplate. J Laryngol Otol. 2008 Jul; 122(7):682-6.
OBJECTIVES: After tympanoplasty using a total ossicular replacement prosthesis, many unsatisfactory hearing results are due to dislocation of the prosthesis. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We developed a cartilage guide for stabilising the total ossicular replacement prosthesis in the oval window niche. An oval-shaped piece of cartilage measuring 2.5 x 3.5 mm with a central hole was precisely punched out of a thin cartilage plate. The cartilage was placed in the oval niche, and its hole centred the prosthesis on the stapes footplate. RESULTS: Hearing results in 52 patients confirmed acoustically the effectiveness of this method of total ossicular replacement prosthesis stabilisation on the stapes footplate. Subsequent 'second-look' surgery revealed stable ingrowth of the cartilage 'shoe' into the oval niche. CONCLUSION: Such a cartilage shoe might address one of the causes of unsatisfactory hearing following ossicular chain reconstruction with a total ossicular replacement prosthesis.
Charles S. Coffey, Fu-Shing Lee, Paul R. Lambert: Titanium versus Nontitanium Prostheses in Ossiculoplasty. Laryngoscope 118: September 2008, 1650-1658
Objectives/Hypothesis: To compare the hearing outcomes and complications observed using either titanium or nontitanium prostheses in a 7-year consecutive series of ossiculoplasties performed by a single surgeon.
Study Design: Retrospective.
Methods: A database of ossicular reconstruction surgeries was reviewed for preoperative and postoperative audiometric data including air and bone conduction thresholds at four frequencies and speech reception thresholds. Outcomes were evaluated at time points less than and greater than 6 months postoperatively. Baseline demographic and surgical characteristics and postoperative complications were also noted.
Results: A total of 105 cases had sufficient audiometric data available for analysis, including 80 performed with titanium and 25 with nontitanium implants. Follow-up ranged from 1.2 to 74.2 months, with a mean of 14.9 months. Mean air-bone gap at initial follow-up was 21.7 dB in the nontitanium group and 15.4 dB in the titanium group; this difference was significant (P = .01). Postoperative air-bone gap of less than 20 dB at initial follow-up was achieved in 50.0% of nontitanium cases and 77.1% of titanium cases (P = .012). This difference in "success" rates persisted at longer follow-up but did not achieve statistical significance. Mean speech reception thresholds at <6 months was 29.7 dB in the nontitanium group and 22.6 dB in the titanium group (P = .049). Extrusion was observed with two nontitanium prostheses (8.0%) and three titanium prostheses (3.8%) (P > .05).
Conclusions: Titanium ossicular prostheses provide hearing outcomes superior to those of nontitanium prostheses when evaluated within 6 months after ossiculoplasty
(C) The American Laryngological, Rhinological & Otological Society, Inc.
G. Schimanski, U. Steinhardt, A. Eiber: Development of a new CliP prosthesis for the Stapes. Middle Ear Mechanics in Research and Otology: Proceedings of the 5th International Symposium by Alex Huber (Editor), Ing Albrecht Eiber (Editor). World Scientific Publishing (9. Juli 2007)
275 inserted Clip-Pistons type '~Wengen" within three years revealed difficulties in 14.5% of the cases. In those cases it was necessary to make adjustments to the clip shape (plastic deformation) before insertion due to the individual dimension of the long incudal process. During 100 middle ear surgeries the cross sections of the long incudal processes where the clip is attached was measured. This resulted in data hitherto unknown. By virtue of a Finite Element Model (FEM) these data were used for optimizing the clip shape. Design criteria were a minimal variation of the contact force for different cross-sections and to minimize the force necessary to slide the clip over the incudal process. The new clip has a lower stiffness and can therefore be applied onto different incus diameters. The lower contact force reduces the risk of arrosion. Due to its optimized shape, the maximal stress in the clip is lowered preventing plastic deformation during the application procedure. The application force was decreased by up to 45% depending on the application points. This leads to easy and safe application reducing the risk of damaging the ossicular chain.
M. Yung: Titanium prosthesis with malleus notch: a study of its “user-friendiness”. The Journal of Laryngology & Otology (2007), 121,938-942.
Department of Otolaryngology, The Ipswich Hospital NHS Trust, Ipswich, UK‘User-friendliness’ is an important factor in the choice of ossicular prosthesis. The current titanium prostheses have a flat, open head plate and are designed to sit under the tympanic membrane. Previously, the author had designed titanium prostheses with a malleus notch extension at the head plate. The present study aimed to assess whether these customised prostheses were user-friendly, compared with conventional prostheses.Fourteen surgeons were recruited to examine the user-friendliness of several ossicular prostheses. They performed ossiculoplasties on temporal bones and rated the user-friendliness of the malleus notch prosthesis against that of some of the more popular conventional ossicular prostheses. For malleus-stapes assembly, eight out of 13 surgeons preferred the malleus notch prosthesis to the Düsseldorf and Goldenberg designs. For malleus-footplate assembly, six out of 10 surgeons preferred the malleus notch prosthesis to the Düsseldorf and Richards designs. Most of the surgeons stated that the reconstruction was more stable using the malleus notch prosthesis.
R. Häusler, U. Steinhardt: A New Self-Fixing and Articulated Malleus Grip Stapedectomy Prosthesis. In W. Arnold, R. Häusler: Otosclerosis and Stapes Surgery. Adv Otorhinolaryngol, (2007) Vol 65, 197-201
Department of ENT, Head and Neck Surgery, Inselspital, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
A new prosthesis for malleus-grip stapedectomy is presented: the Clip® Piston MVP according to Hausler. The titanium piston is equipped with a self-fixing clip mechanism for automatic fixation of the prosthesis on the proximal malleus handle as well as a ball and socket articulation allowing easy introduction of the piston at an optimal angle into the oval window as well as adjustment of the insertion depth. A first series of malleus-grip stapedectomies performed with the Clip® Piston MVP shows a hearing gain of 20 to 50 dB and a residual air-bone gap of </=20 dB in all cases. In one patient, revision surgery was necessary because of piston ejection from the oval window. It appears that with the new Clip® Piston MVP the previously difficult surgery of malleus-grip stapedectomy has become straight forward and technically simpler.
Thelen A(1), Bauknecht HC(2), Asbach P(2), Schrom T(1): Behavior of metal implants used in ENT surgery in 7 Tesla magnetic resonance imaging. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2006 Oct;263(10):900-5. Epub 2006 Jul 12.
(1) Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Charité, Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Klinik für Hals-, Nasen-, Ohrenheilkunde, Campus Mitte, Schumannstr. 20/21, 10117 Berlin, Germany
(2) Institute of Radiology, Charité, Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Campus Mitte, Schumannstr. 20/21, 10117 Berlin, Germany
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has become increasingly important as an imaging technique in cross-sectional imaging of head and neck diseases. To investigate whether MRI examinations can be performed without risk in patients with metal implants even at higher field strengths, we examined different materials in 7 Tesla MRI. Implants near sensory organs like the middle ear or eye are of particular interest here. Using the 7 Tesla research MRI for small animals, we tested implants made of various metals like titanium, gold, gold/platinum, platinum/iridium, gold-plated silver, PTFE and stainless steel for heating, translocation and rotation according to a standardized protocol. A fiber optic temperature probe measured the heating of the implant before, during and after MRI scanning. None of the implants showed significant heating. The gold-plated stainless steel ventilation tube was the only implant to markedly change its position already in the Petri dish. Of the remaining implants, a trachea support ring, a nose dilatator and the wire from the ventilation tubes moved during vibration of the Petri dish. With exception of two implants, all implants changed positions in the water bath. In the swim test, the gold implants showed the least movement of all the implants. In this study, the properties of the non-ferromagnetic implant materials differed in the 7 Tesla MRI. Stainless steel ventilation tubes, the trachea support ring and the nose dilatator were not suited for the 7 Tesla MRI system, because they changed their position during MRI. In the case of ventilation tubes with a steel wire, the wire should be removed before MRI to prevent injury to the external auditory canal. There was a tendency for the pure gold implants to move less in the 7 Tesla MRI than all other tested materials. General statements cannot be made about the MRI suitability of different implants. Every implant should be individually examined to confirm its definitive MRI compatibility. Particularly, middle ear implants warrant special attention here due to their closeness to the oval window.
S. Schmerber, J. Troussier, G. Dumas, JP. Lavieille, DQ. Nguyen: Heraring results with the titanium ossicular replacement prostheses. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol (2006) 263: 347-354.
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, University Hospital of Grenoble, 38043, Grenoble Cedex 9, France, SSchmerber@chu-grenoble.fr.
The purpose was to study the hearing results in patients receiving a Kurz titanium Bell partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) or an Aerial total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP). The study was a retrospective chart review in a tertiary otologic referral center. A computerized otologic database was used to identify 111 patients implanted with either a PORP or TORP prosthesis. Audiograms were reviewed and air-bone gaps were calculated for each patient. The improvement of the average air-bone gap (ABG) was 10.2 and 12.7 dB at 3 and 20 months after ossiculoplasty, respectively. Sixty-six percent of patients (73/111) had a postoperative air-bone gap of 20 dB or less. The ABG for the titanium PORP prosthesis was 14.3+/-9.7 dB, compared with 25.2+/-13.7 dB for the TORP prosthesis ( P <0.05). The ABG to within 20 dB or less was obtained in the PORP group in 77% of the cases, versus 52% of the cases in the TORP group ( P <0.05). Two extrusions of the prostheses were observed at 17 and 20 months after surgery (1.8%). Revision procedures for functional failure were carried out in 20 patients (18%). The rate of sensorineural hearing loss was 3.6%. The major factors influencing good audiometric results were the surgical procedure preserving the external auditory canal and the presence of the stapes. The best hearing results were achieved when a PORP was used in an intact canal wall (ICW) procedure, and the worst hearing results were achieved when a TORP was used in a canal wall down (CWD) procedure. The titanium Kurz prosthesis has been an effective implant at our institution for ossicular reconstruction.
MEMRO 2006, 4th International Symposium on Middle Ear Mechanics in Research and Otology: Selected abstracts.
Tympanoplasty today - an analysysis of 11000 cases of reconstructive middle ear
surgery - the Würzburg experience
J. Müller, F. Schön, S. Brill, J. Helms, R. Hagen, Würzburg; Germany
Nowadays middle ear surgery is not only done to treat mastoiditis and to prevent its complications, which are highly dangerous. Middle ear surgery is also done to restore the hearing. Ojala summed up the situation in the seventies when he stated that „hearing after tympanoplasty usually does not improve (and in some cases even deteriorates)“. Since Wullstein (Würzburg) discribed the basic principles of tympanoplasty in the early 50ties, many other otologists made additional contributions to our current knowledge of tympanoplasty. The aims of tympanoplasty have been and still are:
• the elimination of the pathological changes
• to create stable conditions and easy access for postoperative care
• to reconstruct the sound conduction mechanism.
Numerous grafting materials have been recommended for the closure of tympanic membrane perforations. This paper evaluates three different grafting materials for the reconstruction of the tympanic membrane:
• Perichondrium-Cartilage Composite Graft
The study is based on a computerized documentation system called „Würzburger Ohrbogen“. This system includes now more than 11000 patient’s records. The database comprises information on surgical details (324 items) and patients follow up. All patients included in the study had a minimum follow up of 6 months.
The aim of the study was to analyse the audiological results of different grafting materials, which were
combined with ossicular chain reconstruction. In general, the audiological results achieved in ears which needed a tympanoplasty type I or III showed postoperatively for 80 % of the patients an improved hearing compared to preoperatively. The best hearing results were achieved in those ears in which primary tympanoplasty type I was performed without ossicular chain reconstruction (type I tympanoplasty). The grafting materials we used (perichondrium, cartilage palisades, perichondriumcartilage composit graft (PCCG)) showed 6 months postoperative a similar
air bone gap. The audiograms were measured for the frequencies from 0.5 kHz to 8 kHz. Hearing results were best at 2 kHz. As expected, those patiens who requiered type III TORP tympanoplasty enjoyed less hearing recovery than those who required a type I tympanoplasty or a PORP.
Perichondrium and the cartilage techniques led to simular results. It should not be unmentioned that repreferations occured. The perforation closure rate in type III tympanoplasties was 92.3%, the total repreferation rate was 7.7 %. Based on temporal bone studies using a laser doppler vibrometer also the influence and the audiological quality of different middle ear protheses is discussed. The results of the temporal bone study as well as the initial clinical findings using a new light titanium (n=396) prostheses are discussed. Not surprisingly the combination or different graft materials and different protheses led to similar clinical results except in type III TORP tympanoplasty. In these type of tympanoplasty with a reconstruction of the ossicular chain between stapes footplate and reconstructed eardrum significant better results were obtained when using cartilage.
Based on our data we can conclude that tympanoplasty nowadays is able to improve the hearing.
Coupling problems in middle ear reconstruction
T. Zahnert, Dresden; Germany
The normal and reconstructed middle ear can be considered as a mechanical vibrating system. After the implementation of tympanoplasty as a standardized surgical technique various reconstruction techniques and implants were suggested for the reconstruction of the tympanic membrane and the ossicular chain. Laser–Doppler-vibrometry and model calculations have given new insight into the vibration modes of the normal and reconstructed middle ear during the recent years. Nowadays it can be concluded, that not only material properties of implants but also coupling factors have an important influence on good hearing results. We investigated coupling factors between tympanic membrane and the surrounding bone, between the tympanic membrane and middle ear implants and between the prosthesis and the ossicular chain using model calculations and temporal bone experiments. The quality of the tympanic membrane, which can be considered as the “motor of the middle ear”, has the most important impact on the sound transfer to the inner ear. Ventilation and mucosa problems can damp the tympanic membrane vibrations as well as the reconstruction techniques or the mechanical properties of transplants. The coupling of the tympanic membrane to either the surrounding bone or the cartilage transplants has an influence on the stiffness. The contact of the tympanic membrane to the malleus handle is of importance in order to allow good sound conduction to middle ear prostheses in the high frequency range. Furthermore the contact of prostheses to the stapes head or the footplate may influence hearing results. In our investigations the angle of prostheses towards the tympanic membrane and the stiffness of coupling plays an important role. Concerning the angle it is of importance to distinguish between the x and y – direction. An absolutely stiff contact between malleus and stapes can reduce the sound transfer and increase the risk of prosthesis dislocation or even damage of the annular ligament. Even nowadays modern middle ear reconstructions can only simulate the simple function of a columella. In future it may be important to invent middle ear implants which will be able to fulfill both required middle ear functions – the sound transfer and the compensation of atmospheric pressure changes. It can be assumed that hearing results may improve due to an unstressed coupling of middle ear prostheses by taking the above mentioned techniques and findings into consideration.
Initial experience with titanium MVP clip prosthesis
PP. Singh, New Delhi; India
Introduction: After introduction of stapes surgery malleovestibulopexy (MVP) was the natural extention of this procedure. Although the hearing results of stapes surgery were ususlly excellent, the hearing results of MVP were quite variable. This probably resulted from poor understanding of middle ear mechanics and usage of the same prosthesis as used for stapes surgery. Modification of prosthesis design and technique has resulted in improved hearing outcomes after this procedure. Purpose: To evaluate the hearing outcomes of malleovestibulopexy using titanium MVP clip prosthesis which has recently been introduced.
Material and Methods: Six patients undergoing exploratory tympanotomy for congenital conductve hearing loss or failed stapes surgery and requiring malleovestibulopexy are included in this study. Extended tympanomeatal flap was employed for exposure of middle ear and upper malleus handle. The prosthesis was introduced and the clip was slipped on malleus handle. Minor adjustments were required to attain the perpendicularity of the shaft and shaft insertion in the vestibule. Drilling of handle with diamond burr was required in half the cases to better adapt the clip on malleus handle.
Results: The mean of air-bone gap averaged over speech frequencies was within 20 dB in all six cases and within 10 dB in four cases. No deterioration of bone conduction threshold was observed. Conclusions: The hearing resuts of malleovestibulopexy using newly introduced titanium MVP clip prosthesis have been encouraging and almost equal results of stapes surgery. The improved results seem to be consequent to the unique design of the prosthesis which factors in two key variables of this procedure viz anchorage of prosthesis on malleus handle and perpendicularity of the prosthesis shaft in relation to stapes footplate.
Development of a new clip-piston prosthesis for the stapes
G. Schimanski1, U. Steinhardt2, A. Eiber3,
Luenen1, Dusslingen2, Stuttgart3; Germany
Inserting 275 Clip-Pistons type "a`Wengen" within three years have revealed difficulties in about 15 % of the cases. In that case it was necessary to deform the clip plastically before insertion due to the different dimension of the long process of incus. During more than 100 middle ear surgeries in the region where the clip is attached the cross section of the long process of incus was measured. This led to data which have not been known before. By virtue of a Finite Element model these data could be used for optimization of the form of clip. Design criteria were a minimal variation of the contact force for different cross sections and a minimal force to sliding on the clip over the incus process. The new clip design has a lower stiffness and therefore it is applicable for different diameters of incus process. The lower contact force reduces the risk of arrosion. Due to its optimized shape, the maximal stress in the clip is lowered which prevent a plastic deformation during insertion. The force to slip on the clip could be decreased by one third. This leads to an easy and safe application reducing the risk of amaging the ossicular chain like luxations of incus-stapes joint.
Laser doppler vibrometry data of the Clip piston MVP
A. Arnold, CH. Stieger, R. Häusler, Berne; Switzerland
Background: A new malleus handle prosthesis for malleo-vestibulopexy and revision stapedotomy has been developed at our departement and successfully used during the last five years. The piston prosthesis bears the CliP®-mechanism to facilitate attachment to the malleus handle and length and position can easily be adjusted intraoperatively with a movable hinge.
Objective: The study was devised to determine if the special developed hinge of the CliP Piston MVP causes a loss of sound transfer from the malleus grip to the vestibulum. Methods: A middle ear model was set up, consisting of a vibrator normally used in an active implantable hearing device with a metal arm in shape and dimension of an actual malleus handle, where the CliP Piston MVP was attached with the hinge bend to an angle of about 120°. The piston end of the prosthesis dipped in a hole of a plastic container filled with water simulating a piston hole in the footplate. The excitation level corresponded to more than 110 dB SPL for frequencies between 100 Hz – 10000 Hz. With a laser doppler vibrometer the movements were picked up at different spots in the area of the clip, the
hinge and the piston.
Results: The overall characteristics of the transferfunction was practically identical (difference < 3dB). Additionally biphasic resonance peaks (5-10 dB) were observed around 1000 Hz. Discussion: Our results show very stable transfer properties over the frequency band. The noticed resonance peaks of 5-10 dB are very probably below significance level in clinical pure tone audiometry. This is in accordance with our experience from clinical practice.
Conclusion: The CliP Piston MVP provides good transfer characteristics from the malleus
handle to the vestibulum.
Ossiculoplasty with titanium prostheses
M. Romer, M. Vorburger, A. Huber, Zurich; Switzerland
Objective: To determine the hearing results and the complication rate one year after ossiculoplasty with the Kurz titanium system
Material and Methods: A retrospective chart review of 82 procedures in 77 patients. Included in the study were 36 Aerial-TORP and 46 Bell-PORP between October 2001 and October 2004. The air and bone conduction thresholds as well as the complication rate were evaluated.
Results: The mean preoperative air bone gap (ABG) was 32,9 (+/-13,4)dB. 16 (+/-7,2) months postoperatively the average ABG was 17,6 (+/-11,8) dB. The extrusion rate was 3/82 (3,7%). In one case (1,2%) the prosthesis perforated the stapes footplate and was dislocated into the vestibule without significant sensorineural hearing loss. The tympanic membrane reperforation rate and the cholesteatoma recurrence rate was 3/82 (3,7%) and 1/82 (1,2%) respectively.
Conclusion: The Kurz titanium prosthesis system provides hearing success comparable with current ossiculoplasty studies and low complication rate.
HP. Zenner, R. Zimmermann, U. Steinhardt, M. Maassen: Variable length titanium prostheses for type III tympanoplasty : Intraoperative length adjustment and fixation of the cartilage overlay. HNO 2006 March 24. (German)
Universitats-Hals-Nasen-Ohren-Klinik, Elfriede-Aulhorn-Str. 5, 72076, Tubingen,
INTRODUCTION: For type III tympanoplasty by partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) or total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP), the length of the prosthesis must match the individual intraoperative anatomical and physiological characteristics. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Databanks were used to determine the necessary sizer length of the sizer disc. The measurement template for the size of the cartilage to overlay the prosthesis headplate was derived from the headplates of the Tuebinger titanium prostheses (TTP®) and the Dresdener titanium prostheses. Finally all functions were integrated into a synthetic plate.RESULTS: The result was a simple and reasonably priced disposable multifunctional instrument (Tuebinger sizer disc TSD) which allowed an exact measurement for every prosthesis in TORP and PORP. For the TTP®-Variac, the TSD enabled the simple intraoperative production of prostheses with the length desired by the surgeon. For PORP the TSD enabled an adaptation of the diameter of the prosthesis foot for TTP®, TTP®-Vario and TTP®-Variac and provided a template for the size determination of the cartilage overlay of the titanium prosthesis head. The sizers and the resulting prostheses were used for initial tympanoplastic operations. Audiometric investigations carried out 6 weeks postoperatively gave results corresponding to those previously obtained in a study with TTP® and TTP®-Vario using the old instrumentation. CONCLUSIONS: The new instrumentation leads to an improvement of the intraoperative practicability and a simplification. The audiological results remain the same.
DQ. Nguyen, N. Morel, G. Dumas, J. Troussier, JP. Lavieille, S. Schmerber: Ossiculoplasty with KURZ titanium prosthesis. Ann Otolaryngol Chir Cervicofac. 2005 Sep;122(4):187-93. (French)
Service ORL, CHU, 38043 Grenoble cedex 09. DQNGuyen@chu-grenoble.fr
OBJECTIVES: Report the functional and anatomic results of ossicular reconstruction by titanium prosthesis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Retrospective chart reviews were performed for 111 patients who had undergone titanium ossicular implants between November 1998 and 2002 (61 PORP, 50 TORP). The anatomical and audiometric data were analyzed on average at 3 and 20 months. RESULTS: At 20 months, the improvement of air-bone-gap mean was 12.7 dB with better results at low frequencies. The global success rate was 66% (PORP 77%, TORP 52%). It decreased significantly in the open techniques. Extrusion rate was low (2/111) and the labyrinthization rate was 3.6%. Twenty patients required a surgical revision (18%). In 9 patients, the prosthesis was too short. At long-term follow-up, the gains were stable in 60 patients, improved in 32 patients and worsened in 19 patients. CONCLUSION: The success rate is higher in the group of the PORP with the closed technique. The stability of the TORP in open technique still remains problematic. In all cases, the risk of extrusion requires a large cartilage graft recovering the plate of the prosthesis. The high rate of luxation (9/111 prosthesis too short) has led us to increase slightly the length of the prosthesis (+1.22 mm mean).
W. Grolman, RA. Tange: First experience with a new stapes clip piston in stapedotomy. Otology & Neurotology 2005 July;26(4):595-8
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands. W.Grolman@AMC.UVA.nl
OBJECTIVE: Hearing results after 23 implantations of a newly designed titanium-clip stapes piston prosthesis (the aWengen Clip Piston prosthesis) in patients with otosclerosis were evaluated. This new
type of stapes piston was designed to avoid the crimping onto the incus in stapedotomy. This one clip fits all designs and enables solid fixation by clicking the prosthesis onto the long process of the incus without crimping. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective pilot study was carried out by microcomputer of the preoperative and postoperative audiological results of patients in whom the titanium-clip stapes piston prosthesis was implanted. SETTING: Ear, nose and throat department of Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands. PATIENTS: 23 Patients underwent a stapedotomy for hearing improvement suffering from otosclerosis. implantations of a newly designed titanium-clip stapes piston prosthesis (the aWengen Clip Piston prosthesis) in patients with otosclerosis were evaluated. INTERVENTION(S): The stapedotomy was performed with the aWengen Clip Piston prosthesis. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): Pre and postoperative audiograms were used to evaluate the hearing gain improvement with the new stapes piston. Especially we looked at the airbone gap closure and the sensorineural hearing after the surgical procedure and compared these with the ones before surgery. RESULTS: The hearing results showed a closure of the pure-tone average air-bone gap to within 10 dB in 56.6% of cases (10 of 23 implantations) and to within 20 dB in 100% (23 of 23 implantations). A residual air-bone gap of greater than 20 dB was seen in the present pilot study. Postoperative overclosure of bone-conduction thresholds was discovered only for the frequency of 2 kHz. Sensorineural hearing loss greater than 10% did not occur, and there was no decline in the speech discrimination. CONCLUSIONS: The use of a newly designed titanium-clip stapes piston prosthesis with a diameter of 0.4 mm gives good results in cases of stapedotomy for otosclerosis. The titanium-clip design is a new development in the evolution of stapes piston prostheses. Surgical introduction, placement, and fixation are not always easy, depending on the anatomy of the middle ear and the thickness of the fixation area on the long process of the incus.
Angela D. Martin, Colin L.W. Driscoll, Christopher P. Wood, Joel P. Felmlee: Safety evaluation of titanium middle ear prostheses at 3.0 tesla. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2005; 132:537-542.
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN 55901, USA.
OBJECTIVE: To assess the magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) safety of titanium middle ear prostheses at 3.0 tesla (T). STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Titanium middle ear prostheses from 3 commercial vendors were examined for magnetic field interactions at 3 T. Initially, ex vivo studies were performed to test for rotational motion and forward displacement (translational motion) of the prostheses in a static magnetic field. If movement was observed during this screening study, then the prosthesis was tested to determine the translational or rotational force acting upon the prosthesis. In addition to testing for prosthesis displacement, temperature changes of the prostheses were measured to assess for radiofrequency heating during imaging. RESULTS: Twenty-one of the 24 titanium prostheses tested revealed no movement when tested in the 3 T static magnetic field. Three prostheses revealed minimal movement during the screening study. A translational force test (string test) was performed upon these 3 prostheses, and the measured angle of displacement was used to determine the force. This calculated force acting upon each prosthesis was essentially zero. Therefore, we conclude that the magnetic field interaction is negligible. A positive control with a ferromagnetic stainless steel prosthesis demonstrated obvious displacement during the screening study, as well as deflection of the prosthesis by 90 degrees in the translational force test. Last, heating of the titanium prostheses did not occur in the 7 models tested. CONCLUSIONS: Middle ear prostheses made from titanium are safe,
neither deflecting nor heating during magnetic resonance examinations conducted at 3 T. EBM rating: C-1.
M. Maassen, H. Löwenheim, M. Pfister, S. Herberhold, J. Rodriguez Jorge, I. Baumann, A. Nüsser, R. Zimmermann, S. Brosch, H.-P. Zenner: Surgical-handling properties of the titanium prosthesis in ossiculoplasty. ENT – Ear, Nose & Throat Journal, Vol. 84, No. 3; March 2005
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, University of Tubingen, Elfriede-Aulhorn-Str. 5, D-72076 Tubingen, Germany. email@example.com
Despite the wide variety of ossiculoplasty techniques that are available, success rates are limited. Current use indicates that surgeons prefer ceramic, autograft bone, and plastic pore prostheses. During the past decade, titanium prostheses have been used with great promise. Although their use is not widespread, satisfaction rates are high. An earlier study of ossiculoplasty showed that titanium prostheses were effective in reducing conductive hearing loss. To date, the surgical-handling attributes of titanium middle ear prostheses have not been assessed. We report the results of our survey of 32 otologic surgeons who used the open Tubingen titanium prosthesis for primary and revision ossiculoplasty during tympanoplasty in 400 patients at 12 academic and nonacademic otolaryngology clinics, most of them in Germany. Because the audiometric efficacy of titanium prostheses has been previously reported, our primary outcomes measures included ease of use with respect to the amount of time required to prepare the implants for placement and the surgeons' overall impression of the intraoperative handling characteristics of the implants, taking into consideration factors such as positioning, length adjustment, visibility, and the stability of the coupling. Surgeons also compared the properties of the titanium implant with those of gold, ceramic, and autograft implants that they had used in the past. Based on the results of 383 of the 400 ossiculoplasties, our survey revealed that the titanium implant was significantly superior to the others in all measured respects.
P. Dost, D. Arweiler-Harbeck, K. Jahnke: A prospective evaluation of the Essen titanium stapes prosthesis. Clinical Otolaryngology 30: 21-24 (2005)
Department of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology, University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany. firstname.lastname@example.org
OBJECTIVES: This is the first clinical trial to evaluate the suitability of a new titanium stapes prosthesis, which we developed jointly with the Kurz Company (Dusslingen). DESIGN: In a prospective clinical study, patients with otosclerosis underwent stapes surgery using our new titanium stapes prosthesis during a period of 14 months. One year after surgery pre- and postoperative audiograms were performed and all patients participated in a structured interview. SETTING: Tertiary otorhinolaryngological university department PARTICIPANTS: Of 49 patients with otosclerosis, entering the study, two patients were excluded, because they were not located any more. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES AND RESULTS: All patients experienced a hearing improvement of 21 dB on average except one patient. Sixty percentage of patients achieved a reduction of the air-bone gap to less than 10 dB and 31% of patients having their air-bone gap closed to within 20 dB--averaged across 0.5, 1.0, 2.0 and 4 kHz. The hearing level improved significantly in the air and in the bone conduction thresholds. CONCLUSIONS: This paper presents our first '1 year postimplantation' results of our titanium stapes prosthesis. We consider the development of this implant to be beneficial. The results confirm significant improvement in hearing status and tinnitus levels.
K.-B. Hüttenbrink, Th. Zahnert, E.G. Wüstenberg, G. Hofmann: Titanium CliP Prosthesis. Otology & Neurotology 25:436-442 (2004)
Department of ORL, Technical University of Dresden, Dresden, Germany. email@example.com
OBJECTIVE: Prostheses for the reconstruction of a defective ossicular chain should be stable and firmly anchored to the ossicular remnants. This will prevent a defective connection from causing diminished sound transmission efficiency and will keep the prosthesis from tilting or even losing contact, which would result in a sound transmission block. Through temporal bone experimentation, we have consequently developed a very lightweight titanium prosthesis, which is fastened onto the stapes head with a clip mechanism. METHODS: When temporal bone experiments using laser Doppler vibrometry confirmed that the prosthesis functioned well acoustically and when luxation experiments proved that it could be safely used without the risk of stapes dislocation, the prosthesis was used in a clinical application within an observational study. The University of Dresden Otorhinolaryngological Hospital as well as seven surgeons from five other hospitals participated in the study. RESULTS: The results of 133 operations showed that, in over 90% of the cases, the prosthesis could be implemented without problems and with good mechanical stability. The first acoustical results obtained during the first year from 49 patients showed a sound transmission improvement range from 12 dB to 14 dB. CONCLUSION: With the clip prosthesis, it seems possible to further improve defective middle ear function, which would allow the patient to regain social hearing after middle ear reconstruction. The reliability of the fastening is an innovation. Revision operations showed a stable prosthesis-stapes complex in the middle of a recurring cholesteatoma and the prosthesis could always be easily pulled from the stapedial suprastructure.
K.-B. Hüttenbrink, Th. Zahnert, D. Beutner, G. Hofmann: The Cartilage Guide: A solution for Anchoring a Columella-Prosthesis on the Footplate. Laryngo-Rhino-Otol 2004; 83: 450-456. (German) English translation available.
BACKGROUND: A torp (columella-prosthesis) is the typical ossicular reconstruction in cases of a destroyed stapedial arch. Yet, many unsatisfactory hearing results are due to the lack of a stable, reliable anchoring of the base of the prosthesis on the footplate. Some solutions have been postulated, amongst them the perforation of the footplate with a tiny spike at the lower end of the prosthesis, which, however, many otosurgeons regard as too dangerous for the inner ear. Specially designed silicone sheets cannot guarantee a permanent guide of the columella. METHODS: From our good experience with cartilage in different reconstruction procedures, we therefore developed a cartilage guide for the oval window niche. An oval 2,5 x 3,5 mm cartilage with a central hole is cut out of a thin (0,2 - 0,3 mm) cartilage plate with a help of a cartilage punch, which we had designed in collaboration with Heinz Kurz manufacture. The cartilage is placed into the oval niche and its hole guides the prosthesis onto the centre of the footplate. RESULTS: Temporal bone experiments demonstrated a reliable sound transport through this guide. Revision surgery revealed a stable ingrowth of the cartilage plate into the oval niche, its perforation securely guiding the prosthesis similar to a piston on to the footplate. The first short time hearing results (max. 1 year) in 22 patients confirmed the acoustic quality of this stabilisation of a columella on the footplate as compared to a matched control group. CONCLUSIONS: The stabilization of the columella with a cartilage-guide might solve one of the many problems with unsatisfactory hearing results after the reconstruction of a completely destroyed ossicular chain.
D.Q. Nguyen, J.-P. Lavieille, S. Schmerber : Failure rate and revision surgery in ossiculoplasty with Kurz titanium prostheses. Rev Laryngol Otol Rhinol. 2004; 125,3:157-162. (French)
CHU Grenoble, Service ORL, F-38043 Grenoble cedex 09, France. DQNGuyen@chu-grenoble.fr
Despite its excellent biocompatibility, failures and in particular extrusion of the prosthesis have been described in ossiculoplasty with titanium prosthesis. OBJECTIVE: Report our experience with revision ossicular recontruction in ossiculoplasty with Kurz prosthesis. Identify causes of failure in ossiculoplasty using the titanium prosthesis. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Retrospective chart reviews were performed for 110 patients who had undergone titanium ossicular implants between November 1998 and 2002. All patients had undergone ossiculoplasty using titanium middle ear implants. Patients were divided into 2 groups: in group 1 patients underwent revision ossiculoplasty; in group 2 patients had a successful surgery at first stage. Anatomic and functional results have been studied in these two groups. Causes of failures were analysed. RESULTS: The overall failure rate was 20% (22/110). Twenty patients underwent revision ossiculoplasty. Nine primary failures were attributable to a short implant. Two extrusions were observed. At long term billow-up, the functional gain between the primary and revision ossiculoplasty was comparable. CONCLUSION: Revision ossiculoplasty is worthwhile for those patients who have failure of the titanium prosthesis in ossiculoplasty. A large cartilage graft interposition is necessary to prevent extrusion. The overall luxation rate observed in our series was mainly due to a too short prosthesis and we recommend now a reconstruction with longer prosthesis.
H.P. Zenner, H.-G. Freitag, C. Linti, U. Steinhardt, J. Rodriguez Jorge, S. Preyer, P.-S. Mauz, M. Sürth, H. Plank, I. Baumann, R. Lehner, A. Eiber: Accoustomechanical properties of open TTP® titanium middle ear prostheses. Hearing Research 192 (2004) 36-46.
Department of Otolaryngology, The University of Tubingen, Germany. firstname.lastname@example.org
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of the study was to identify acoustcomechanical properties of various biostable and biocompatible materials to create a middle ear prosthesis with the following properties: (i) improved handling including a good view of the head of the stapes or footplate and adjustable length, (ii) improved acoustical characteristics that are adequate for ossiculoplastic. The identified material should serve to build CE and FDA approved prostheses for clinical use in patients. METHODS: Test models made of Teflon, polyetheretherketone, polyethylenterephtalate, polysulfone, gold, Al2O3 ceramics, carbon and titanium were investigated for their potential to fulfill the requirements. Acoustical properties were investigated by laser Doppler velocimetry (LDV) in mechanical middle ear models (MMM). Measured data were fed in to a recently created computer model of the middle ear (multibody systems approach, MBS). Using computer-aided design (CAD) measured and computed data allowed creation and fine precision of titanium prostheses (Tubingen Titanium Protheses, TTP). Their handling was tested in temporal bones. Acoustomechanical properties were investigated using the MBS and mechanical middle ear models. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Input impedance, mass, stiffness, and geometry of test models and prostheses were determined. Furthermore, their influence on the intraprosthetic transfer functions and on coupling to either tympanic membrane or stapes was investigated. RESULTS: Final results were FDA- and CE-approved filigreed titanium prostheses with an open head that fulfilled the four requirements detailed above. The prostheses (TTP) were developed in defined lengths of between 1.75 and 3.5 mm (partial) and 3.0 and 6.5 mm (total) as well as in adjustable lengths (TTP-Vario). CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest acoustomechanical advantages of TTPs because they combine a significantly low mass with high stiffness. In contrast to closed prostheses, the open head and filigreed design allow an excellent view of the prosthesis foot during coupling to the head or footplate of stapes, contributing to an improved intraoperative reliability of prosthesis coupling.
Edward K. Gardner, MD; Gary Jackson, MD; David M. Kaylie, MD: Results with Titanium Ossicular Reconstruction Prostheses. Laryngoscope 114: January 2004.
The Otology Group, Nashville, Tennessee, USA. email@example.com
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Despite the enthusiasm of recent short-term reviews, no center in the United States has published results meeting American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery guidelines with titanium-based prostheses. The purpose of the study was threefold. The first purpose was to review results with a titanium prosthesis system in cases meeting American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery reporting guidelines. The second was to compare these results with previously published results using non-titanium-based prostheses. The third was to examine the authors' results for any evidence of a "learning curve." STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective chart review was performed for the period from February 2000 to August 2001 and for the period from July 2002 to February 2003. METHODS: Of 313 cases, 130 consecutive cases were identified in the first period and 65 in the second time period. One hundred two patients had adequate follow-up for published guidelines. All cases were performed by the senior author (c.g.j.). Comparison data were obtained from a previous publication involving the senior author. RESULTS: Successful rehabilitation (<or=20 dB pure-tone average air-bone gap) of conductive hearing loss was obtained in 70% of partial ossicular chain reconstructions and 44% of total ossicular chain reconstructions when titanium prostheses were used. Comparison data revealed successful rehabilitation in 48% and 21% of non-titanium-based partial and total reconstructions, respectively. Postoperative pure-tone average air-bone gaps were not significantly different when compared with results in the period from July 2002 to February 2003. CONCLUSION: Newer titanium-based ossicular reconstruction devices represent an improvement over previously used non-titanium-based prostheses. The authors think that this improvement is realized rapidly because no learning curve existed in their data.
Angela D. Martin, MD; Stephan G. Harner, MD: Ossicular Reconstruction with Titanium Prosthesis. Laryngoscope 114: January 2004.
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905, USA.
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the results when using titanium total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP) or partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) in chronic ear disease. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective chart review was performed. METHODS: Sixty-eight ossicular procedures using a titanium TORP (n = 30) or PORP (n = 38) were performed at a tertiary referral center between December 1999 and June 2002. The ossiculoplasty was performed either alone or in combination with other chronic ear surgery. Cartilage grafts were used universally. Nineteen percent were primary operations, and 6% were planned second stages. The majority were revision procedures. Follow-up ranged from 3 months to 2.5 years. RESULTS: The prosthesis is easy to insert, well tolerated, and has a low extrusion rate. Average air-bone gap (ABG) improvement was 13 dB with closure of the ABG to within 20 dB in 57% of cases. Hearing results were better for primary versus revision cases for PORPs versus TORPs and for intact canal wall (ICW) procedures versus canal wall-down (CWD) procedures. CONCLUSION: Titanium is a satisfactory material for use in ossicular reconstruction because of its ease of insertion, tissue tolerance, and low rate of extrusion. Caution is advised when selecting candidates for this procedure during revision surgery, especially if the canal wall and stapes superstructure are absent.
C.L. Zuur, A.J.G. de Bruijn, R. Lindeboom, R.A. Tange: Retrospective analysis of early postoperative hearing results obtained after stapedotomy with implantation of a new titanium stapes prosthesis. Otology & Neurotology 24:863-867 (2003)
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Academical Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands. firstname.lastname@example.org
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the early postoperative hearing results of a new titanium stapes prosthesis (K-Piston) implanted in patients with otosclerosis. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective analysis of preoperative and early postoperative hearing thresholds. SETTING: One tertiary referral and teaching hospital. PATIENTS: Eighteen men and 40 women, mean age 47 years, with otosclerosis. INTERVENTION: Primary stapedotomy. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Main outcome measures were the mean gains in bone-conduction and air-conduction pure-tone thresholds, and pure-tone averages for different frequency combinations. Success and failure of the individual cases were presented using Amsterdam Hearing Evaluation Plots. RESULTS: The overall postoperative air-bone gap for the frequency combination 0.5-1-2-4 kHz was 8.4 (standard deviation: 5.2) dB. In 79% of the patients the postoperative air-bone gap was less than 10 dB. Air-conduction improved even in higher frequencies, while the Carhart effect was not seen in most cases. In three patients a deterioration of bone-conduction was observed ranging from 11 to 16 dB sound pressure level (SPL), and in four patients the gain in air-conduction was insufficient (3-29 dB SPL) to close the preoperative air-bone gap to within 20 dB. CONCLUSION: The new low-weight, full-titanium stapes prosthesis with its slight rough surface and its good mechanical stability and biocompatibility can safely and successfully restore the function of the middle ear when implanted in patients with otosclerosis.
24th Politzer Meeting 31 August – 4 September 2003, Amsterdam, the Netherlands: Selected abstracts
115. PRELIMINARY OSSICULOPLASTY RESULTS USING THE KURZ® TITANIUM MIDDLE EAR IMPLANTS.
Heylbroeck Ph.,De Vel E. Et Dhooge I.
Department of Otorhinolaryngology and Head- and Neck surgery, Ghent University Hospital, De Pintelaan 185, Ghent, Belgium
Titanium has been an accepted prosthetic material for decades in craniofacial and orthopaedic surgery. The last decennium, studies were published reporting the results of titanium prostheses used for ossiculoplasty. The new. lightweight titanium prostheses are designed to maximize visualization of the capitulum and footplate region. Mechanically they are characterized by a high degree of rigidity and low weight. Acoustically they have low sound damping, low acoustic impedance, and a second resonance that might increase to broadband frequency transmission. These characteristics suggest the possibility of improved signal transfer in the main speech frequencies at around 2 kHz. A prospective clinical study was started to evaluate the efficacy of the variable (= adjustable length) Tübingen titanium prosthesis (TTP-Vario). Twenty patients were evaluated. A canal wall up procedure was performed in 3 cases, a canal wall down procedure in 17 cases. A postoperative air bone gap of < 20 dB was obtained in 60% of bell prosthesis patients and < 25dB in all bell prosthesis patients. The pure-tone average air-bone gap for the aerial prosthesis was < 20 dB in 43%, < 25 dB in 64% and < 30 dB in 85% at 1 month. The results were stable or improved for later time intervals. To date there have been no extrusion. The surgeon finds the prosthesis easy to handle and the open head of the prosthesis facilitates correct placement on the capitulum of the stapes or on the footplate. From a surgical point of view, the Kurz titanium prosthesis is an excellent middle ear prosthesis due to the design and the possibility of individual adjustment. The hearing results are good. Further studies are needed to confirm long-term efficacy.
119. ANATOMICAL AND FUNCTIONAL RESULTS OF TITANIUM PROS-
THESES IN MIDDLE EAR OSSICULOPLASTY
Gerard J.M., Blaivie C., Decat M., Garin P., Gersdorff M.
University Hospital Saint-Luc, ENT Department, 10 Av. Hippocrate, 1200 Brussels Belgium
In the majority of chronic middle ear disease, there is an ossicular chain defect. Various types of prostheses are used for ossiculoplasties. The most common are autogenous or allogenous bone or cartilage, plastipore. hydroxyapatite, bioactive glass and many other prostheses. Since a few years different metals were also available, like gold and titanium. Between November 1997 and January 2003, 77 patients were operated for chronic ear disease. Two types of titanium ossicular prostheses were used for ossiculoplasties (40 Spiggel and Theis® and 37 Kurz®). We performed interpositions of the tragal or allograft cartilage. The mean age was 41 years old and the average follow- up was 31 months for the Spiggel and Theis® and 5 months for the Kurz®. We used 43 total ossicular prostheses (TORP) and 34 partial (PORP). One patient had a prosthesis extrusion after a postoperative infection. All others had stable anatomical results. The pure tone average air-bone gap (PTA-ABG) was calculated on 500,1000, 2000 and 4000 Hz in preoperative and at the last postoperative consultation.
For the TORPs, the PTA-ABG ≤ 20 db was found in 55% of the cases for the Spiggel and Theis® and 63% for the Kurz®. For the PORPs it was 54% for the Spiggel and Theis® and 71 for the Kurz®.
Titanium ossicular prostheses offer advantages compared to other prostheses having a very easy and simple surgical manipulation, excellent anatomical sta- bility and good functional results The Kurz® prostheses procured us better functional results because of the sizer prostheses set which permits a better evaluation of the height and the right position of the prosthesis.
138. T.T.P. VARIO MIDDLE EAR IMPLANTS - EXPERIENCE OF TWO YEARS
Leelavati Hospital Mumbai India
Titanium Vario Implants by Kurz Company was used in 83 patients. The idea was to compare vario with standard size implants. The convenience of use was compared. 66 implants were of Bell type and 17 were of Arial type. All these implants were covered by a piece of cartilage. Due to the exact length, of the implant, they could be placed in optimum position. In very rare cases, where reconstruction is needed between Vestibule and tympanic membrane, TTP vario can be combined with cartilage to make a composit implant. In terms of hearing improvement, on an average TTP vario gives 7 dB higher improvement than the standard fixed length implant. In terms of optimality it has a great advantage over the fixed length implant. There is zero percent extrusion. TTP vario could be considered as one of the best materials to be used in middle ear reconstruction. Due to it's versitility, there is hardly any situation where one will find difficulty to reconstruct.
154. NO MORE CRIMPING: THE NEW CLIP PISTON AWENGEN `
Visiting Professor at HNO-University Hospital Basel, Switzerland
Objective: Crimping of the stapes prosthesis might result in injury to the incus. Attachment is often not tight. Facilitated fixation of a stapes prosthesis could improve surgery and provide more stable results.
Method: After development of a unique titanium clip over a seven year period (Kurz AG, Dusslingen Germany) and reception of a CE-mark, the first implantation was performed in September 2000. Full FDA approval was received in June 2002. Up to May 2003 more than 2400 Clip Piston àWengen have been purchased in several countries around the world.
Results: Only 60% of the circumference of the incus is touched by the clip permitting adequate mucosal blood supply to the lenticular process. Application of the prosthesis is quick and stable. There is no need for crimping anymore. The clip holds precisely in the main axis of movement of the long process of the incus.
Conclusion: This new stapes prosthesis facilitates surgery and reduces OR-time. There is no need for crimping anymore. Acoustic coupling is ideal due to the spring action of the self-retaining clip. Most surgeons have switched entirely to this prosthesis. Long-term results will be needed to prove the reduction of incus necrosis. In the nearly three year period of observation since the first implantation there was no loosening of the clip.
Alexander M. Huber, Furong Ma, Heidi Felix, Thomas Linder: Stapes Prosthesis Attachment: The effect of Crimping on Sound Transfer in Otosclerosis Surgery. Laryngoscope 113: May 2003
Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, University Hospital of Zurich, Switzerland. email@example.com
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Although in stapes surgery successful hearing improvement may be achieved in the majority of patients, unsatisfactory closure of the air-bone gap can be recorded. One of many reasons for unexpected failures of stapes surgery may be the insufficient crimping of a stapes prosthesis onto the incus. The objectives of the study were to assess the amount of sound transmission loss in response to the quality of prosthesis crimping and to identify a required loop attachment pattern to obtain good sound transmission results. STUDY DESIGN: Experimental. METHODS: A temporal bone model was developed to measure the sound transmission properties between incus and prosthesis on 17 fresh human temporal bones. The attachment of a titanium stapes piston was assessed without crimping, followed by loose crimping and tight fixation to the incus, using scanning laser Doppler interferometry, endoscopic photography, micro grinding technique, and scanning electron microscopy. An algorithm had to be developed to simulate acoustical stimulation using electromechanical stimulation. RESULTS: Optimal tight crimping of the stapes piston revealed consistent good sound transfer function ranging from 0 to 7 dB loss, and loss remained, on average, at 2 dB. The mean transmission losses for conditions of loose crimping and no crimping were surprisingly small (within 10 dB). However, these unusual crimping conditions allowed a wide range of losses up to 28 dB. A close coupling at least at two opposite points was obligatory to obtain consistently good results. CONCLUSIONS: Perfect hearing reconstruction necessitates ideal crimping of a prosthesis to obtain consistently good results. However, the final functional gain depends on many different intraoperative and postoperative factors.
Alex Battaglia, Benjamin M. McGrew, Gary Jackson: Reconstruction of the Entire Ossicular Conduction Mechanism. Laryngoscope, 113:654-658: April 2003
Department of Head Neck Surgery, Southern California Kaiser Permanente Medical Group, 3033 Bunker Hill Street, San Diego, CA 92109, USA. firstname.lastname@example.org
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Stapes fixation combined with fixation, absence, or malformation of the malleus-incus complex requires an uncommon surgical reconstruction and offers a unique combination of challenges and hazards. This situation may occur in the presence of severe tympanosclerosis, otosclerosis, congenital ossicular malformations, and revision surgery for either stapedectomy or chronic ear disease. In previous reports, this procedure has been grouped with total ossicular reconstruction without much distinction. However, the challenges unique to this problem deserve special consideration. The present report offers a treatment plan for a group of patients requiring reconstruction of the entire ossicular conduction mechanism including removal of the stapes footplate. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review. METHODS: Three thousand three hundred fifty (3350) charts of patients requiring total ossicular replacement prostheses (TORPs) were reviewed. Of this group of patients, only 21 of 3350 patients from 1977 to 1999 required TORP placement and removal of the stapes footplate. The patients were followed for an average period of 50 months. RESULTS: Hearing results indicated an overall improvement in the air-bone gap of 10 dB, with 52% achieving an air-bone gap of less than 20 dB. Of the 21 cases, 5 revision surgeries were performed. Three were performed because of a displaced TORP (14.2%). and 2 were performed because of extruded TORPs (9.5%). CONCLUSIONS: Reconstruction of the entire ossicular conduction mechanism including removal of the stapes footplate can be successfully achieved with improvement of the air-bone gap of less than 20 dB. Hearing results and extrusion rates are comparable to reported results of TORP placement on a mobile footplate. Successful stapedectomy and simultaneous ossicular chain reconstruction can be performed as a single or staged procedure. Special attention is paid to avoid intrusion of the prosthesis into the vestibule.
Steven Y. Ho, Robert A. Battista, Richard J. Wiet: Early Results With Titanium Ossicular Implants. Otology & Neurotology 24: 149-152 (2003)
Department of Otolaryngology, Northwestern University School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois, USA. email@example.com
OBJECTIVE: To report the efficacy of titanium middle ear prosthesis for ossicular reconstruction. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective chart reviews were performed for 25 patients who had undergone titanium ossicular implants between January 1, 1999, and June 1, 20001. SETTING: Tertiary otology referral center. PATIENTS: All patients had a minimum of 6 months of postoperative follow-up and no evidence of recurrent otologic disease. INTERVENTION: All patients had undergone ossiculoplasty using titanium middle ear implants. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Comparisons of preoperative and postoperative pure tone averages were performed. Air-bone gap closures and implant extrusion rates were measured.RESULTS Overall mean pure tone averages improved 22.2 dB with air-bone gap improvement at 20.9 dB. Fifty-six percent of patients achieved air-bone gap less than 20 dB postoperatively. The overall extrusion rate was 4%. However, with the placement of cartilage graft interposed between the prosthesis and the tympanic membrane, no extrusion was observed. CONCLUSION: Titanium implants provide comparable hearing improvement compared with other materials. The extrusion rate seems quite low if cartilage interposition graft is inserted. Its ease of handling, biocompatible properties, and sound conducting properties improve its efficacy as an ossicular implant.
A. Neumann, H-J. Schultz-Coulon, K. Jahnke: Type III Tympanoplasty applying the Palisade Cartilage Technique: A Study of 61 Cases. Otology & Neurotology 24: 33-37 (2003)
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, University of Essen, Germany. firstname.lastname@example.org
OBJECTIVE: To determine the morphologic and hearing results of the combined application of the palisade cartilage technique and titanium ossicular replacement prostheses in Type III tympanoplasty. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review of 61 tympanoplasties. SETTING: Tertiary referral center. PATIENTS: 59 patients (39 women and 20 men, mean age 36 years, range 7-81 years) consecutively operated on because of cholesteatoma, adhesive otitis, chronic otitis media, subtotal tympanic membrane defects, and tympanofibrosis requiring tympanoplasty with ossiculoplasty. INTERVENTIONS: Tympanoplasty Type III, with application of the palisade cartilage technique and total or partial titanium ossicular replacement prosthesis. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Otoscopic findings and hearing results using a four-frequency pure tone average air-bone gap. RESULTS: A recurrent defect was seen in 1 ear (1.6%). The graft take rate was 100%. There were no extrusions of prostheses. Preoperatively, a pure tone average air-bone gap of 0 to 10 dB was seen in 1 ear, 11 to 30 dB in 30, and 31 to 50 dB in another 30 ears. Postoperatively, the corresponding numbers were 11, 41, and 9 ears, respectively. Hearing results were better in the total ossicular replacement prosthesis group. CONCLUSIONS: The palisade cartilage technique is suitable to manage difficult pathologic conditions in middle ear surgery. It was demonstrated that the palisade cartilage technique can be combined safely with titanium ossicular replacement prostheses. Regarding postoperative hearing results, the negative preselection of pathologic conditions must be considered.
Brian W. Downs, James M. Pearson, Carlton J. Zdanski, Craig A. Buchman, Harold C. Pillsbury: Revision Ossicular Reconstruction with the Titanium Kurz Prosthesis. Laryngoscope 112: August 2002
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, North Carolina 27599-7070, USA. email@example.com
OBJECTIVE/HYPOTHESIS: One European multicenter study has reported favorable outcomes after ossicular reconstruction with the titanium Kurz prosthesis. At the time of this study, however, no study has analyzed its outcomes when used for reconstruction after prior failure with another implant (revision reconstruction). The study reports our experience with the titanium Kurz prosthesis for revision ossicular reconstruction. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective review was made of all revision ossicular reconstructions at our institution from October 1998 to September 2001. METHODS: Seventeen cases were reviewed. Patients were divided into two groups: patients who underwent revision ossicular reconstruction with the Kurz prosthesis and patients who underwent revision ossicular reconstruction with another prosthesis (the "other" group). Audiograms were reviewed and air-bone gaps were calculated for each patient. RESULTS: The average postoperative air-bone gap after Kurz revision was 15.6 dB, a statistically significant improvement over the average postoperative air-bone gap from the "other" revision group (P =.022). CONCLUSION: The titanium Kurz prosthesis has been an effective implant at our institution for revision ossicular reconstruction. Future research should focus on a prospective, randomized trial comparing the Kurz prosthesis with other prostheses currently in use.
W.W.O. Krueger, J.G. Feghali, C. Shelton, J.D. Green, C.W. Beatty, D.F. Wilson, B.S. Thedinger, D.M. Barrs, J.T. McElveen: Preliminary Ossiculoplasty Results using the Kurz Titanium Prostheses. Otology & Neurotology 23: 836-839 (2002)
The Otology Group, San Antonio, TX 78240, USA. firstname.lastname@example.org
OBJECTIVE: Limitations in biocompatibility and hearing improvement with ossicular chain reconstruction prostheses are addressed with new, lightweight titanium prostheses designed to maximize visualization of the capitulum and footplate regions. The effectiveness of these new prostheses is being tested in a prospective multicenter study. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective case series. SETTING: Multicenter (8 sites), primarily tertiary private practice or academic otologic clinics. PATIENTS: A convenience sample of 31 patients undergoing ossiculoplasty, with 16 partial ossicular chain reconstructions using the Bell prosthesis and 15 total reconstructions using the Aerial prosthesis. INTERVENTION: Ossiculoplasty using new Kurz titanium prostheses. Cartilage was interposed between the tympanic membrane and the prosthesis. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Air-bone gap for pure tone average and 3,000 and 4,000 Hz, assessed preoperatively and 3 months, 6 months, and 12 months postoperatively; percent of patients obtaining an air-bone gap of </=20 dB; high-frequency average (1,000, 2,000, and 4,000 Hz) to evaluate sensorineural hearing loss; and extrusion rate. RESULTS: A postoperative air-bone gap of </=20 dB was obtained in 81% of Bell prosthesis patients and 67% of Aerial prosthesis patients at 3 months. The results were stable to improved for later time intervals. High-frequency gaps were similar to the pure tone average gap. To date, there have been no instances of extrusion, and all the surgeons found the prostheses easy to use and thought that the design characteristics facilitated accurate placement. CONCLUSIONS: Initial evaluation of the Kurz titanium prostheses produced low extrusion rates (none to date) with excellent hearing results, including good high-frequency conduction. Good visualization and accurate placement were easy to achieve. Further studies are needed to confirm long-term efficacy.
K. Schwager: Titanium as a material for ossicular replacement – basic aspects and clinical application. Laryngorhinootologie 2002 Mar; 81 (3):178-83. (German)
Klinik und Poliklinik fur Hals-Nasen-Ohrenkranke der Universitat Wurzburg, Germany. email@example.com
BACKGROUND: The use of titanium as a biomaterial in ossicular chain reconstruction is increasing. The situation for integration of biomaterials is more difficult in the semiopen implantation site middle ear than in other parts of the body. Important for integration is the contact of the biomaterial's surface toward proteins. Studies of the integration in living tissue still have to be performed in animal experiments. Morphological examinations of explanted prostheses after clinical use complete the picture of an ossicular replacement material. METHODS: Preclinical studies where performed to compare the adsorption behaviour of titanium, stainless steel and aluminum oxide toward radioactive marked albumin and native collagen type I. An animal model in the rabbit was performed to study the integration of titanium in the middle ear morphologically. Middle ear prostheses removed during revision surgery were studied as well. RESULTS: Titanium showed an adsorption amount of 360 microgram/cm(2), stainless steel of 230 microgram/cm(2) and aluminum oxide of 500 microgram/cm(2) out of an albumin solution of 400 mg/ml. Comparing desorption the mean loss was 16 % for titanium, 21 % for stainless steel and 23 % for aluminium oxide. Reassembled collagen fibrils could be detected after adsorption in collagen type I solution by means of scanning electron microscopy. Morphological studies in animal experiments showed regular healing after implantation. Explanted prostheses from humans did not show any cellular signs of repulsion. CONCLUSION: The results of preclinical studies and clinical use demonstrate titanium as a useful material for ossicular reconstruction in middle ear surgery.
H.P. Zenner, A. Stegmaier, R. Lehner, I. Baumann, R. Zimmermann: Open Tuebingen Titanium Prostheses for Ossiculoplasty: A Prospective Clinical Trial. Otology & Neurotology 2001, 22:582-589
Department of Otolaryngology, University of Tuebingen, Tuebingen, Germany.
OBJECTIVE: The overall purpose of the study was the evaluation of the efficacy of Tubingen titanium prostheses (TTPs) for ossiculoplasty. STUDY DESIGN: A two-part clinical study of 216 patients undergoing ossiculoplasty was performed. The first part was a prospective study using TTPs (n = 114). The second part involved study of historical control patients (n = 102) with gold and ceramic prostheses. INTERVENTIONS: All patients underwent ossiculoplasty. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Measures included median air conduction thresholds and air-bone gaps. RESULTS: All patients were per-protocol patients. When the air-bone gap "gold standard" (i.e., < or =10 dB) was investigated in the main speech spectrum, partial TTPs reached this level at 2 kHz in 44% (n = 22) and at 3 kHz in 38% (n = 19). Gold and ceramics revealed significantly lower values. Similar results were obtained for total prostheses. Differences for TTPs and ceramics were statistically significant (Mann-Whitney U test, alpha = 5%). CONCLUSION: The use of TTPs for ossiculoplasty is an efficient treatment method.
K. Begall, H. Zimmermann: Reconstruction of the ossicular chain with titanium implants. Results of a multicenter study. Laryngo-Rhino-Otol 2000, 79 (3):139-145. German (English abstract)
HNO-Klinik, St. Salvator-Krankenhaus, Halberstadt. firstname.lastname@example.org
BACKGROUND: For decades, oto-surgeons have been trying to find suitable alloplastic materials for replacing ossicles in the case of morphological and functional disorders in the middle ear. The focus of attention has been on tissue tolerance and functionality. PATIENTS: A retrospective analysis of the implantation of titanium prostheses is presented (Type "Duesseldorf", Heinz Kurz GmbH, Dusslingen, Germany) in 528 patients operated in 14 ENT hospitals. The hospitals involved are ENT hospitals with different fields of specialization presenting a representative cross-section of surgical ENT treatment. Evaluated were healing results, hearing gain and surgical handling of the implants. RESULTS: Despite pathological middle ear conditions, the tissue-implant healing rate was very high. In 4.4% of the patients the implants were rejected. In the case of partial ossicular reconstruction, an average hearing gain between 10 and 20 dB was achieved. Total reconstruction of the ossicular chain showed even better audiological results (15 to 20 dB on average). CONCLUSION: Due to the good morphological and functional results achieved, titanium implants have proven their worth for middle ear micro-surgery. Their advantages are their light weight and delicate structure, facilitating very good micro-surgical handling. It is advisable to place a thin layer of cartilage between the prosthesis headplate and the tympanic membrane. In this manner, the number of material extrusions can be safely reduced, however, extrusions cannot completely be avoided.
Dirk Mürbe, Thomas Zahnert, Matthias Bornitz, Karl-Bernd Hüttenbrink: Acoustic properties of different cartilage reconstruction techniques of the tympanic membrane. Laryngoscope 112: October 2002
Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Dresden University Hospital, Dresden, Germany. email@example.com
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: The use of cartilage in reconstruction of the tympanic membrane has been established especially in cases such as tubal dysfunction and adhesive processes. Cartilage offers the advantage of higher mechanical stability compared with membranous transplants but may alter the acoustic transfer characteristics of the graft.
Apart from material properties, it can be assumed that, also, the microsurgical reconstruction technique might influence the sound transmission properties of the reconstructed tympanic membrane. The purpose of the study was to investigate the acoustic transfer characteristics of different cartilage transplants being typically used in different reconstruction techniques of the tympanic membrane. METHODS: Cartilage plates of different thicknesses (1.0, 0.7, 0.5, and 0.3 mm), cartilage palisades, and cartilage island transplants of varying size were investigated by means of an ear canal-tympanic membrane model. In contrast to former single-point measurements, sound-induced vibrational amplitudes of the entire transplant were measured by scanning laser Doppler vibrometry (measuring points, n = 133) (PSV-200, Polytec, Waldbronn, Germany). Frequency response functions (displacement vs. sound pressure) of all measured points were determined in the frequency range of 200 Hz to 4 kHz for the different transplants. RESULTS: Cutting thick cartilage transplants into thin plates or palisades decreased the first resonance frequency and increased its amplitude, reflecting improved sound transmission properties of the transplant. From an acoustical point of view, the 0.5-mm cartilage plate seems preferable compared with the palisade technique. Cartilage island techniques showed vibration characteristics superior to plate or palisade techniques. CONCLUSIONS: Apart from material characteristics, the sound transmission properties of the reconstructed tympanic membrane are strongly influenced by the reconstruction technique. The choice of the surgical technique should consider requirements based on mechanical stability and acoustic transfer characteristics of the transplant.
T. Zahnert, Hüttenbrink K.B., Mürbe D., Bomitz M.: Experimental investigations of the use of cartilage in tympanic membrane reconstruction. Am J Otol 2000, 21 (3):322-328
Department of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology, Dresden University of Technology, Germany.
BACKGROUND: Temporalis fascia, perichondrium, and cartilage are commonly used for reconstruction of the tympanic membrane in middle ear surgery. Cartilage grafts offer the advantage of higher mechanical stability, particularly in cases of chronic tubal dysfunction, adhesive processes, or total defects of the tympanic membrane, in contrast to fascia and perichondrium, which presumably offer better acoustic quality. HYPOTHESIS: The purpose of this study was to determine the acoustic transfer characteristics of cartilage of varying thickness and its mechanical deformation when exposed to fluctuations in atmospheric pressure. METHOD: Ten pairs of cartilage specimens from the cavum conchae and the tragus were obtained from fresh human cadavers. Young's modulus was determined by mechanical tension tests and statistically evaluated using the t test. The acoustic transfer characteristics of an additional 10 specimens were measured by a laser Doppler Interferometer after stimulation with white noise in an external auditory canal--tympanic membrane model. Mechanical stability was determined by measuring displacement of the cartilage using static pressure loads of < or = 4 kPa. RESULTS: Young's modulus determinations for conchal and tragal cartilage were 3.4 N/mm2 and 2.8 N/mm2, respectively, but the difference was not significant. Acoustic testing showed a 5-dB higher vibration amplitude in the midfrequency range for conchal compared with tragal cartilage, but the difference was not significant. Reducing cartilage thickness led to an improvement of its acoustic transfer qualities, with a thickness < or = 500 microm resulting in an acceptable acoustic transfer loss compared with the tympanic membrane. CONCLUSION: Both conchal and tragal cartilage are useful for reconstruction of the tympanic membrane from the perspective of their acoustic properties. The acoustic transfer loss of cartilage can be reduced by decreasing its thickness. A thickness of 500 microm is regarded as a good compromise between sufficient mechanical stability and low acoustic transfer loss.
CH. Stupp, C. Dalchow, D. Grun, HF. Stupp, J. Wustrow: Three years experience with titanium implants in the middle ear. Laryngorhinootologie 1999 Jun;78(6):299-303. (German)
Klinik fur HNO-Heilkunde, Kopf- und Hals-Chirurgie, St. Elisabeth Krankenhaus, Koln-Hohenlind.
BACKGROUND: In continuation of our previously published report on initial experience with titanium implants in the middle ear , we now present the results of routine use over a three year period. METHODS: From November 1994 to November 1997, 661 titanium implants (Dusseldorf model) were implanted in the authors' clinics (355 PORP, 306 TORP). There was no preselection of patients. Five hundred eighty-two follow up examinations were performed with a medium follow up time of 11.6 months. RESULTS: The good initial results of the previous study with respect to biocompatibility and functional hearing results were confirmed in the long term follow-up. The average air-bone gap was calculated over the frequencies 0.5, 1, 2, and 4 kHz. Closure to within 20 dB was achieved in 72% of cases. The air-bone gap tended to decrease with increasing time of implantation. Adverse reaction to the prostheses did not occur. Extrusion occurred in one case of complete middle ear atelectasis with resorption of the interposed cartilage. Insufficient improvement of hearing was attributable to a short implant in 12 cases (1.8%). In three cases (0.5%) insufficient stability of the PORP was attributable to eroded stapes suprastructure, and in three others (0.5%) a dislocation was responsible for a poor hearing result. Middle ear fibrosis with impairment of sound transmission was seen in 3 patients (0.5%). CONCLUSION: The superior acoustic properties of the delicate yet rigid low-weight titanium implants combined with excellent biocompatibility lead to a good hearing result if a meticulous surgical technique is employed. The easy handling makes it a pleasure to work with these protheses.
K. Schwager: Titanium as an ossicular replacement material: results after 336 days of implantation in a rabbit. Am J Otol. 1998 Sep;19(5):569-73
Klinik und Poliklinik für Hals-, Nasen- und Ohrenkranke, Universität Wurzburg, Germany.
The middle ear poses unique challenges when finding suitable materials for ossicular reconstruction, primarily because of its link to the external environment via the eustachian tube and, hence, its greater exposure to infectious agents. In this study, the biocompatability of titanium was examined in the middle ear of rabbits by using light and scanning electron microscopy. Implants were placed as middle ear prostheses or as free implants. These were inspected at 28 days, 84 days, 168 days, 336 days and 504 days following implantation for mucosal coverage, percent epithelization and any sign of foreign-body reaction. After 28 days, the prostheses were covered by regular mucosa. Although a majority of the free implants took up to 336 days for complete epithelialization, some of the free implants were not epithelialized even at day 504. There were no inflammatory cells observed on the surface of the material, nor were unusual amounts of fibrous tissue seen. In addition, the titanium material exhibited an affinity toward bone. The results of this animal experiment indicate that titanium is a favorable material for ossicular replacement prostheses.
CH. Stupp, HF. Stupp, D. Grun: Replacement of ear ossicles with titanium prostheses. Laryngorhinootologie 1996 Jun;75(6):335-7. (German)
HNO Klinik, Dominikus Krankenhaus, Am Heerdter Krankenhaus 2, 40549 Dusseldorf, Germany. firstname.lastname@example.org
OBJECTIVES: Since 1994 more than 1300 titanium implants have been used to reconstruct the ossicular chain of the middle ear for chronic otitis media. Two different types of implants were used. First, a total and a partial implant of fixed length, available in numerous different lengths. And second, a total and partial implant that has an adjustable length. The implants are commercially available from 2 different companies. Patients were followed for a postoperative term from 6 to 72 months.
METHODS: A wide variety of patients aged 5 to 82 years received a tympanoplasty type III. Those patients whose ossicular chain had been reconstructed with titanium implants since 1994 were evaluated. As implants from one company are fixed in length; implants of a second company are trimmable in length. All prostheses are lightweight and made of pure titanium, fitting most anatomical situations. RESULTS: Earlier results already showed a very low complication rate. Extrusions occurred only in cases of middle ear atalectasis with resorption of interposed cartilage (<1%). No adverse reaction to the prostheses could be seen, even in histologic reviews. An average air-bone gap less than 20 dB(A) for all calculated frequencies of 0.5, 1, 2, and 4 kHz was achieved for 76% of cases; 43% of cases showed a calculated air-bone gap of less than 10 dB(A), only 10% higher than 30 dB(A). CONCLUSION: All implants used offer the proven benefits of titanium, namely high biocompatibility and high stability at a very low complication rate with excellent hearing results for the patients. Titanium implants can highly be recommended to reconstruct the ossicular chain of the middle ear.
Ventilation Tubes F. Schmäl, M. Nieschalk, K.W. Delank, W. Stoll: Incidence of infection and types of bacteria after drainage of the middle ear in children: Gilded silver tubes vs. silicone tubes. HNO 1999, 47:107-111.
HNO-Klinik, Westfalische Wilhelms-Universitat Munster. Otorrhea is the most common complication after tympanostomy tube insertions. In Germany there are currently two commonly used types of tympanostomy tubes: silicon tubes (ST) and gilded silver tubes (GT). Previously published in vitro studies by Tajima uncovered a positive correlation between the silicon concentration in culture fluid and the rate of growth of Staphylococcus aureus. Our study retrospectively evaluates the types of bacteria and rates of otorrhea after ST and GT insertions. The present study was undertaken to determine which of these tubes had a higher incidence of otorrhea and then whether silicon tubes stimulated the growth of certain types of bacteria, such as Staphylococcus aureus. In all, 186 ST and 59 GT were placed in 245 ears of 144 children. Both ST and GT were separated into three groups: first insertion of a tympanostomy tube, second implantation and insertion of a tympanostomy tube in an infected ear in the course of a mastoidectomy. No differences between ST and GT in causing otorrhea were found in the three groups. Nevertheless, ST in comparison to GT was associated with a higher incidence of infections with Pseudomonas aeruginosa. In contrast, a higher incidence of Staphylococcus aureus related to ST could not be proved. Twenty percent of the ears with mastoiditis were found to have Pseudomonas aeruginosa, but none of these ears implanted with a GT developed postoperative otorrhea. Our findings show that GT should be used when a ventilation tube is used during a mastoidectomy. Further, it is tenable to implant only GT because postoperative otorrhea in many cases is caused by insufficient water protection and water is frequently polluted with Pseudomonas aeruginosa.
Berit Schneider, Doris-Maria Denk, Wolfgang Bigenzahn: Acoustic assessment of the voice quality before and after medialization thyroplasty using the titanium vocal fold medialization implant (TVFMI). Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery: June 2003
Department of Otorhinolaryngology/Section of Phoniatrics-Logopedics, University of Vienna, Vienna Medical School / Austria, General Hospital, Veinna, Austria. Berit.Schneider@akh-wien.ac.at
OBJECTIVE: This study was designed to objectify the vocal outcome in patients with unilateral vocal fold paralysis. Acoustic parameters were evaluated and compared to perceptual voice sound assessments before and after medialization thyroplasty using the titanium vocal fold medialization implant (TVFMI). STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Twenty-eight patients underwent external medialization thyroplasty using TVFMI. Prior to and after surgery videostroboscopy, perceptual voice evaluation and acoustic analysis based on the computerized "hoarseness diagram" were performed. RESULTS: In videostroboscopy, most patients showed an almost complete glottal closure after thyroplasty. The statistical analysis revealed a significant improvement in the perceptual voice parameters (p<0.001). The acoustic measurements could objectify the positive impact on the voice after thyroplasty (p< or =0.001). CONCLUSION: The results confirm that the
TVFMI is an excellent and individually adjustable device for medialization thyroplasty. The "hoarseness diagram" allows the vocal outcome after surgery to be documented and objectified in an easy and reliable manner.
B. Schneider, W. Bigenzahn, A. End, DM Denk, W. Klepetko: External vocal fold medialization in patients with recurrent nerve paralysis following cardiothoracic surgery. Eur J Cardiothrac Surg. 2003 Apr; 23 (4): 477-83
Section of Phoniatrics-Logopedics, Department of Otorhinolaryngology, General Hospital, University Hospital of Vienna, Vienna, Austria. email@example.com OBJECTIVES: Recurrent laryngeal nerve injury is a possible complication following cardiothoracic surgery. Due to insufficient glottal closure, dysphonia and dysphagia with aspiration may occur. The purpose of the study was to outline the effect of vocal fold medialization thyroplasty on voice, swallowing and breathing impairments. METHODS: Between 1999 and 2001, medialization thyroplasty using the titanium implant (TVFMI) according to Friedrich was performed in 14 patients with postoperative left-sided recurrent nerve paralysis (five female and nine male patients, mean age 64 years) by an external approach. Previous surgical procedures comprised six lobectomies (combined with resection and replacement of the subclavian artery in one case), two pneumonectomies, one resection of a schwannoma in the aortopulmonary window, two replacements of the descending aorta, one aortocoronary bypass procedure (with LIMA), and two esophageal resections using Akiyama technique, respectively. Before and after thyroplasty, the patients underwent an otolaryngological/phoniatric examination including videostroboscopy, voice sound analysis, voice range profile measurement, pulmonary function testing, and in selected cases videofluoroscopy of swallowing. RESULTS: Following thyroplasty, all patients reported on subjective improvement of voice, swallowing and breathing functions. Videostroboscopy revealed an improved glottal closure (six complete, six with posterior gap). All voice related parameters (e.g. roughness, breathiness, hoarseness, maximum sound pressure levels of the singing and shouting voices) were significantly improved. CONCLUSIONS: Due to potential risk of recurrent nerve alteration in left-sided intrathoracic procedures, a preoperative and postoperative laryngoscopic examination is recommended. The external medialization of the vocal folds can be regarded as an excellent method for improvement of voice, swallowing and breathing, in particular, when the quality of life is impaired due to persistent recurrent nerve paralysis.
Berit Schneider, Doris-Maria Denk; Wolfgang Bigenzahn: Functional results after External Vocal Fold Medialization Thyroplasty with the Titanium Vocal Fold Medializing Implant. Laryngoscope 113: April 2003
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, University Hospital of Vienna, School of Medicine, Vienna, Austria. Berit.Schneider@akh-wien.ac.at
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: A persistent insufficiency of glottal closure is mostly a consequence of a unilateral vocal fold movement impairment. It can also be caused by vocal fold atrophy or scarring processes with regular bilateral respiratory vocal fold function. Because of consequential voice, breathing, and swallowing impairments, a functional surgical treatment is required. The goal of the study was to outline the functional results after medialization thyroplasty with the titanium vocal fold medialization implant according to Friedrich. METHODS: In the period of 1999 to 2001, an external vocal fold medialization using the titanium implant was performed on 28 patients (12 women and 16 men). The patients were in the age range of 19 to 84 years. Twenty-two patients had a paralysis of the left-side vocal fold, and six patients, of the right-side vocal fold. Detailed functional examinations were executed on all patients before and after the surgery: perceptive voice sound analysis according to the "roughness, breathiness, and hoarseness" method, judgment of the s/z ratio and voice dysfunction index, voice range profile measurements, videostroboscopy, and pulmonary function tests. In case of dysphagia/aspiration, videofluoroscopy of swallowing was also performed. The respective data were statistically analyzed (paired t test, Wilcoxon-test). RESULTS: All patients reported on improvement of voice, swallowing, and breathing functions postoperatively. Videostroboscopy revealed an almost complete glottal closure after surgery in all of the patients. All voice-related parameters showed a significant improvement. An increase of the laryngeal resistance by the medialization procedure could be excluded by analysis of the pulmonary function test. CONCLUSIONS: The results confirm the external medialization of the vocal folds as an adequate method in the therapy of voice, swallowing, and breathing impairment attributable to an insufficient glottal closure. The titanium implant offers, apart from good tissue tolerability, the advantage of an easy, time-saving, and individually adjustable application during the operation.
Gerhard Friedrich, MD: Titanium Vocal Fold Medializing Implant: Introducing a novel implant system for External Vocal Fold Medialization. Ann Otol Rhino Laryngol 108: 1999 ENT-University Hospital, University Medical School Graz, Austria.
With the increasing worldwide spread of the Isshiki technique for external vocal fold medialization, some disadvantages and limitations have also emerged. and an increasing demand for a readymade and standardized implant system can be observed. For this reason. I started experimental and clinical investigations with the goal of replacing the silicone with a safer material, and also simplifying and standardizing the surgical procedure. In particular, the danger of implant dislocation should be excluded with greater certainty. As a result, I have developed an implant made of medical-grade titanium. My surgical experiences in 20 patients with this newly developed titanium vocal fold medializing implant revealed that vocal fold medialization could be performed easily and that no perioperative complications occurred in any case. The major advantage was a significant reduction of operative time due to the preformed implant. This is not only more convenient for both the surgeon and the patient, but is also critical for obtaining optimal results due to the reduced intralaryngeal swelling and hematoma. The reduction of the glottic gap by the operation was statistically significant. Significant improvement of all voice parameters was achieved and demonstrated by a statistically significant reduction of the voice dysfunction index. Compared to the current techniques and implant systems, I see the following additional advantages: 1) titanium is a relatively safe implant material with excellent biocompatibility: 2) the design of the implant ensures optimal fixation and stabilization: 3) the implantation technique and handling is simple and time-saving; 4) the titanium sheet is easy to shape and adapt to the individual situation: and 5) only 2 sizes of implants, and no expensive instruments, are required.
Eyelid weights Thomas Schrom(1), , Ariane Thelen(1), , Patrick Asbach(2), , Hans-Christian Bauknecht(2),: Effect of 7.0 Tesla MRI on Upper Eyelid Implants. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. ;22 (6):480-482 17117110
(1) Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Charité, Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Klinik für Hals-, Nasen-, Ohrenheilkunde, Campus Mitte, Schumannstr. 20/21, 10117 Berlin, Germany
(2) Institute of Radiology, Charité, Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Campus Mitte, Schumannstr. 20/21, 10117 Berlin, Germany
To ensure the MRI compatibility of various eyelid implants in high-field MRI, 3 eyelid weights made of pure gold (99.99%), pure platinum (99.95%), and a platinum (97%)/iridium (3%) alloy were examined in vitro. Temperature changes, position changes, and imaging artifacts of the different implants were determined in a small-bore 7.0 Tesla MRI system. The 7.0 Tesla MRI system demonstrated that none of the eyelid implants carried a risk of heating or dislocation; therefore, these implants are MRI compatible up to a magnetic field strength of 7.0 Tesla.
G. Moser, G. Oberascher: Reanimation of the paralyzed face with new gold weight implants and Goretex soft-tissue patches. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 1997, 254 (Suppl.I): 76-78.
Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, General Hospital, Salzburg, Austria. Although dynamic reconstruction procedures are preferred for treating patients with complete facial paralyses, static procedures are useful for various conditions. One such technique involves the implantation of gold weights into the upper eyelid. We have reported our experiences with 58 patients who underwent gold weight implantation for rehabilitation of eyelid closure with satisfactory results. To obtain better cosmetic results we developed newly shaped thinner weights. Four instead of three perforations in each weight enable better fixation to soft tissue. Since 40% of all cases also required additional surgery to rehabilitate other portion of the face, polytetrafluoroethylene (Goretex) soft-tissue patches were used for suspension to help correct midfacial and perioral asymmetry. From 1990 to 1996, 22 patients underwent this technique under local or general anesthesia. Except for 2 patients, no complications were observed. Overall, both gold implants and Goretex patches were found to provide good results in patients selected
for facial reanimation.